Not Oligarchy, but Capitalism
A Response to the Paris Manifesto from the Front of Class Struggle

Dear Young Comrades,
On 21 November 2026, a manifesto titled “Against the International Oligarchy” was published in Paris. More than a hundred researchers signed the call, including Piketty, Zucman, Saez, Stiglitz, Krugman, Duflo, Acemoglu, Nancy Fraser, Étienne Balibar, Naomi Klein, Axel Honneth and Lea Ypi. The announcement also made the news in Türkiye.
We take the text seriously. That requires speaking plainly. The manifesto identifies a real wound and prescribes the wrong cure. It is valuable because it shows the wound. Its prescription, however, remains within capitalism and proposes to repair it; history has repeatedly shown the limits of that approach.
A note on scope: the text published online is a short appeal. Further detail appears in a book published by Seuil and in press accounts of the longer text. We have not read the book; for those details we rely on Cumhuriyet's reporting.
Summary
What does the manifesto say? Extreme wealth is the major social fact of our time. According to the manifesto, the wealth of the richest 0.0001% of the world's population—about 1,500 households in 1987—was equivalent to 3% of annual global GDP. In 2026, the same population fraction—around 3,000 households—holds wealth equivalent to 17% of annual global GDP. These figures are a wealth stock compared with a yearly flow of production, not a share of total wealth or a share of annual income. The proposed response: a minimum tax on the ultra-rich and recovery of past unpaid taxes; media independence; and an international, deprivatised ownership model for AI companies. The proposed framework is a “democratic International”.
What is valuable?
- The data. The rise in wealth relative to annual global output from 3% to 17% indicates the scale of concentration.
- Recognition that billionaire wealth is not chiefly cash but power over corporations: an implicit observation about ownership.
- The discussion of ownership, not only taxation, in AI.
- The international scale of the question.
What do we oppose?
- The adversary is misnamed. The problem is not oligarchy alone but capitalism. The billionaire is not an accidental departure from the system but a result of it.
- The prescription remains within the system. The 2% minimum tax proposal reported by Cumhuriyet does not alter the relation of exploitation. Taming capital risks rescuing it.
- The state is treated as an arbiter. The state expected to impose the tax is, in our analysis, a capitalist state.
- The collective subject is underdeveloped. The short appeal does not put the collective action of the working class at its centre. Union leaders are among the signatories; our criticism concerns the role assigned to worker organisations, not whether they are present.
- Class struggle is not named. Yet the struggle between labour and capital continues.
What do we propose? We do not reject reform; we reject reformism. We would fight for a wealth tax, but as one front in class struggle, not as a complete solution. The goal is not a tax rate but changing ownership of the means of production. That requires organisation, not signatures alone: the cells, assemblies, backbone and bridges discussed in Organising 2.0.
Naming the adversary: Not oligarchy, but capitalism
“Oligarchy” can be a reassuring word. It can imply that the problem is confined to three thousand households and the rest of the system is healthy. It points to Musk and Trump while leaving the local boss, the factory owner, the subcontractor and the bank out of view.
Marx's argument was that accumulation concentrates and centralises capital. Competition enlarges the large; crises allow them to absorb the small. Monopoly is not merely a breakdown of competition but can be its result. In our view, the wealth of around three thousand households becoming equivalent to 17% of annual global output is not capitalism going astray; it is capitalism working as it does.
There is no stable choice between “good capitalism” and “bad oligarchy” if the former produces the latter. Wanting capitalism without billionaires is like wanting sunshine without a shadow.
Who made the “golden age”, and why did it end?
The manifesto says inequality fell to a historic low after the Second World War and later returned. It invokes that period as a reference point. Let us ask who built its gains and who rolled them back.
They were not the work of clever tax designers alone. An organised working class emerging from war and resistance, mass unions, strike waves, anti-colonial liberation movements and the existence of a socialist bloc all shaped the balance of forces. Capital made concessions under pressure. High taxation was also a result of class struggle.
The rollback came as capital, facing pressure on profits, sought to recover those concessions: weakening unions, relocating production and privatising public assets. In Türkiye, 24 January and 12 September are part of that history.
Our lesson is that concessions must be defended. As long as ownership remains concentrated, capital has the power to try to take them back. A call to restore a “golden age” is not enough without a strategy for the forces that ended it.
Tax: A prescription that leaves exploitation intact
One of the manifesto's strongest observations is that billionaire fortunes consist largely of shares that confer power over companies. Wealth is therefore a relationship of command: power over employment, production and plant closures.
Now consider the prescription. Cumhuriyet reports a proposal requiring people with wealth above $100 million to pay personal taxes each year equal to at least 2% of their wealth. The short online appeal specifies neither a rate nor a threshold. A minimum that takes taxes already paid into account is not the same as an additional 2% tax on the whole fortune.
- Tax addresses distribution after production. In Marxist terms, surplus value is produced through unpaid labour at work; taxation enters after appropriation. It contests part of the proceeds, not the underlying relationship.
- The boss remains the boss after paying the minimum. The power to dismiss, set wages and withhold investment remains.
- Capital can respond: investment strikes, capital flight, media campaigns and warnings of economic collapse. Mitterrand came to office in 1981 with nationalisation and redistribution, then shifted to austerity in 1983 amid currency and capital pressures. In 2015, Greek voters rejected a bailout proposal by about 61%; the Syriza government subsequently signed a new austerity agreement. The Mitterrand government did nationalise major businesses. We read both experiences as illustrating the limits of reforms that do not durably transform property relations and capital's organised power.
Recent setbacks for wealth-tax proposals in France and California have also been reported. In our view the obstacle is not simply a lack of evidence, but a lack of organised power.
The state is not an impartial referee
The manifesto says wealth can buy political influence, then asks politics to impose a tax. We read that approach as treating the state as an institution that democratic pressure can reclaim. The short appeal does not set out a full theory of the state; what follows is our interpretation and criticism.
Marxism argues otherwise. In the Communist Manifesto, the modern state is described as a committee managing the common affairs of the bourgeoisie. On this view, law, finance and coercive institutions are structured to defend property. Strike restrictions, trusteeships and tax amnesties can be understood as actions of the same apparatus.
This does not mean refusing to make demands on the state. We make them and fight for them. But what is won depends on the force exerted from outside it. That force cannot be reduced to a ballot: it includes the ability to organise and halt production.
Class struggle is already under way
Those startled by the words “class war” might remember Warren Buffett's 2006 observation that his class was waging and winning it. The accumulation of wealth relative to output is not a natural event: it is connected to decades of anti-union measures, subcontracting, insecure work, privatisation and debt.
According to Türkiye's Labour Ministry, the official unionisation rate among registered workers in July 2026 was 13.8%. Informal workers are excluded from that denominator. The figure points to the need for stronger organisation.
The manifesto describes a tension between democracy and oligarchy. We think this language can conceal a sharper conflict between labour and capital. To speak of class struggle is not a call for violence; it is a call to organise our side in an existing conflict. Our strength lies in our numbers, organisation and place in production: committees, unions, strikes, workplace occupations, solidarity and political organisation.
AI: Socialisation, not a foundation alone
A deprivatised ownership model for AI companies is among the manifesto's most advanced demands because it raises ownership directly. According to Cumhuriyet's account of the longer text, it cites Wikipedia, Signal and Firefox and proposes governance by international foundations, with workers participating in decisions.
The proposal remains incomplete:
- A foundation is not automatically a barrier to capital. OpenAI began as a nonprofit and created a for-profit entity in 2019. That entity became a public benefit corporation in 2025, while the nonprofit foundation retained control. Mozilla has long depended heavily on its search agreement with Google.
- There is no immaterial commons without material infrastructure. Models require chips, data centres, electricity and water. If the infrastructure remains monopolised, a foundation can remain dependent on its owners.
- These machines depend on our labour. Models are trained on large collections of human writing, images and code, and shaped by data labellers and moderators. A shared accumulation of knowledge—what Marx called the general intellect—is appropriated.
Our demand must be clear: socialise AI together with its infrastructure, under democratic planning and the control of workers and users. And if that is right for AI, why not for energy, banks, medicines, housing and media? We continue that discussion in Public AI.
Whose “democracies”?
The democracies the manifesto wants to save include states that restrict strikes, leave migrants at sea, increase military budgets and constrain solidarity with Palestine. The short appeal refers to the Second World War in historical context but does not discuss imperialism or today's war economy. Yet war economies are a channel of wealth accumulation, and “democracy” is often invoked in a world of competing armed blocs.
We defend rights within bourgeois democracy because working people fought for them and need them to organise. But a democracy that stops at the boundary of property can stop at the factory gate. In our view oligarchy is not an external opposite of bourgeois democracy; it grows out of its property relations.
There is no classless International
The First International was called the International Working Men's Association. Workers' associations and unions played major roles in its foundation; intellectuals such as Marx also participated. Its principle was that the emancipation of the working class must be the work of the working class itself.
The Paris appeal offers an online signature form, while the short text does not explain the role of worker organisations. But the signatories include trade union leaders such as ITUC General Secretary Luc Triangle, ETUC General Secretary Esther Lynch and CGIL General Secretary Maurizio Landini. We must not erase their participation. Instead, we ask: how will an organisation rooted in workplaces, accountable to its base and connecting unions through action be built? An advisory network of signatories alone cannot take its place.
Acemoglu's presence illustrates the limits we discussed in our earlier response: a framework that treats institutions apart from class can criticise oligarchy without naming the relation that produces it. Signatories such as Fraser and Balibar explicitly discuss capitalism. Our comradely question to them is: how can capitalism, unnamed in the short appeal, be confronted within this programme's limits?
Organising 2.0: Organisation, not signatures alone
In Organising 2.0 we distinguished two kinds of action. Duty action may soothe the conscience and be forgotten tomorrow. Campaign action has a timetable, a demand, a measure and builds capacity. A signature without organisation behind it risks remaining the first kind.
| Layer | Organising 2.0 | Paris Manifesto |
|---|---|---|
| Cell | Lasting workplace, neighbourhood or campus committees of 5–30 people | Not specified in the short appeal |
| Assembly | Open meetings with elected, recallable delegates | Not specified in the short appeal |
| Backbone | Unions, federations, professional and political organisations | Union leaders have signed; organisational arrangements are unspecified |
| Bridge | Cross-border solidarity from workplace to workplace | International appeal present; workplace links unspecified |
We said: “A network without a backbone disperses; a backbone without a network ossifies.” The Paris short appeal does not explain how such a backbone and cells will be built. The fifth principle of Organising 2.0 was “ask about ownership”; the seventh was “cross borders”. We need both: an international class organisation rooted in workplaces and asking who owns what.
Two paths side by side
| Paris Manifesto | The front of class struggle |
|---|---|
| Extreme wealth is the problem | Exploitation and private ownership of the means of production are the problem |
| Adversary: oligarchy | Adversary: the capitalist class as a whole |
| Conflict: democracy and oligarchy | Conflict: labour and capital |
| Tool: a minimum tax | Tool: organised class power; tax is one front, not the solution |
| State: addressed by demands for taxation and regulation | State: a class apparatus to be pressured and ultimately superseded |
| Deprivatised AI ownership; foundations in press accounts of the longer text | Socialisation with infrastructure and worker control |
| Subject: “democratic forces” | Subject: the working class and its allies |
| Participation: signature | Participation: committees, assemblies, unions and strikes |
| Horizon: reforming the existing order | Horizon: a classless society |
This table contrasts the online appeal and our own programme; it should not be read as an exhaustive account of the unpublished details of every signatory's position.
Reform? Yes. Reformism? No.
Let there be no misunderstanding: if a wealth tax came to a vote tomorrow, we would support it and mobilise for it. Rosa Luxemburg's distinction remains relevant: reform struggle is a means; social transformation is the goal. Workers who fight for reforms organise, discover their strength and encounter the limits of the existing order. That is why we pursue each reform demand.
What we reject is making reform the horizon. A programme of merely “fixing capitalism” risks teaching workers to wait, trust experts and vote. We want to organise, trust our collective strength and ask about ownership.
What is to be done? Concrete tasks
- Share the figure and name the relation. The manifesto's wealth-to-annual-GDP ratio rises from 3% to 17%. Ask alongside it: how much has the employer's income grown, and how much have wages grown?
- Build a committee. Five people from the same workplace or neighbourhood meeting weekly can begin to build a durable base.
- Read the manifesto together and write a response. One page: what do we agree with, oppose and propose?
- Join a union; if none exists, organise one; if one does, work to transform it. A movement needs a backbone.
- Connect the tax demand to collective power. Make a wealth tax a joint union demand during budget negotiations, backed by a timetable for action.
- Ask about ownership in every struggle. In a dismissal, closure or privatisation: who owns this workplace, and who should?
- If you work in tech, take the demand for socialised AI to your union or professional chamber and connect with data workers.
- Build the bridge from the workplace. Contact workers at the same company in another country or unions in the same sector abroad.
- Read. The Communist Manifesto, Luxemburg's Social Reform or Revolution and Lenin's State and Revolution all discuss questions raised again in Paris.
Conclusion
Dear Young Comrades, when Nobel-winning economists begin to speak of an “International”, we should recognise the opening in the existing order's own defence of itself. But we should enter it with our own programme, not simply theirs.
They want to tax billionaires. We want to end the system that makes billionaires possible. They want to limit oligarchy. We want to abolish classes. They collect signatures. We organise.
Not democracy against oligarchy alone, but labour against capital. An International is built not only from lecterns, but from committees.
A broad network, a strong backbone.
This article is a version open to criticism and contributions.
Sources
- Paris Manifesto: Against the International Oligarchy, 21 November 2026; signatories.
- Cumhuriyet: Paris Manifesto published, 22 November 2026.
- Télérama: the Paris Manifesto and wealth taxation; Türkiye's Labour Ministry: July 2026 union statistics; OpenAI: Our structure.
- Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, The Communist Manifesto (1848); Rosa Luxemburg, Social Reform or Revolution? (1899); Vladimir Lenin, State and Revolution (1917).
- Knowledge Commons: Organising 2.0, Public AI and the Economist–Acemoglu debate.









