Knowledge Commons
HomeTopicsSeriesGuidesPopularAboutContact

A Class Diagnosis, an Incomplete Programme

A Comradely Reading of the Peoples' Climate Summit Final Declaration

17 min readAuthor: Oğuz Demirkapı
A Class Diagnosis, an Incomplete Programme
Dear Young Comrades,

Two summits took place at the same time in Antalya. The first was COP31 at the Expo site, where heads of state, energy companies and lobbyists gathered, some arriving by private jet. We described this contrast in the first article in our series, Two Climate Summits in Antalya, and the Class of the Crisis, and then asked whose agenda was on the Antalya table. The second was the Peoples' Climate Summit (Halkların İklim Zirvesi, HİZ) at the Mimar Sinan Congress Centre in Kepez. After the Global Day of Action march on 14 November, workers, peasants, women, young people, trade unionists, scientists and defenders of life gathered there from 15 to 18 November. According to the organisers' announcement, around 150 events with speakers from 32 countries were planned.

On 18 November the summit issued its final declaration. Its title is "Defending Life, Rebuilding the World".

We write neither as outsiders grading the declaration nor as people applauding it without question. This should be read as a conversation between people marching in the same contingent. For the first time, an international-scale peoples' climate summit was organised in Türkiye. Those who made it happen spent months volunteering and arranging buses. They found venues, translated and brought numerous events together in one programme. We respect that work. Because we respect it, we take the text seriously and discuss it. A left that is not afraid of criticism can only be built by reading comrades' texts carefully.


First, a Summary: Eight Theses

  1. The diagnosis starts in the right place. The declaration describes the climate crisis not as a technical malfunction but as a product of the capitalist mode of production and capital accumulation. It says that "the collective power of the working class is decisive". This goes beyond the usual NGO climate language.
  2. The meaning of a just transition is broadened. Transition is not limited to energy; agriculture, mining, transport, waste and care work are included.
  3. The strongest demand concerns the workplace. The right to stop work in dangerous climate conditions without loss of pay could be written directly into a collective agreement.
  4. The ownership question remains unfinished. Capital accumulation is identified as the root cause, but there is no demand explicitly addressing ownership of fossil-fuel capital. Nationalisation and socialisation of companies do not appear in the written declaration.
  5. The concept of imperialism is absent. North–South division uses the language of geography. Türkiye's intermediate position as a country subject to exploitation that also exports capital is not visible.
  6. Two languages, two texts. In the long written declaration we examined, the English version contains explicit demands concerning Akkuyu and Sinop; the Turkish version has no nuclear section. However, the shorter declaration read aloud in Turkish at the summit called for an end to nuclear expansion. The difference between the written versions needs explanation.
  7. The addressee is unclear. The text is written against COP, yet still expects something from COP mechanisms. It does not name the government at home.
  8. There is a position, not yet a programme. The issues are important, but the declaration does not specify priorities, a timetable or responsible organisations. Turning it into an action programme depends on choosing demands and taking them into workplaces and unions.

Let us consider these theses in turn.


What Does the Declaration Say?

The text was published in Turkish and English. Its main subjects are:

  • Rights of nature and ecocide: criminalising ecocide, opposing "green extractivism" and recognising local communities' rights.
  • Palestine: condemning Israel's attacks in Gaza, ending the occupation, accountability for war crimes and the Palestinian people's right to self-determination.
  • Fossil-fuel phase-out and energy democracy: energy systems under public oversight, cooperatives and community-based models.
  • War and peace: reducing military spending and redirecting it to climate finance, and developing "democratic peace" in Türkiye.
  • Food sovereignty: agroecology, seed rights and a ban on hazardous pesticides.
  • The right to water: opposing privatisation and market control, fair watershed management, and transparent oversight of water use by data centres and artificial intelligence infrastructure.
  • Waste and planned obsolescence: ending waste exports and producing durable goods.
  • Loss and damage, and a just transition: grant-based, directly accessible climate finance and cancellation of unjust debts of the Global South.
  • False solutions and science: criticism of carbon markets and risky geoengineering, science independent of corporate interests, transformed intellectual-property regimes and an initial atmospheric carbon dioxide target of 350 ppm.
  • The Public Pathway: rights rather than charity after disasters, socialisation of care, workers not being forced to choose between "breath and bread", energy as a basic right and cities reorganised around rights rather than rent.
  • Solidarity: monitoring negotiations and corporations, joint campaigns, international networks and the goal of meeting again in Ethiopia next year.

Even this list shows how wide-ranging the declaration is. Both its strength and its weakness arise from that breadth.


Why Does It Matter? The Declaration's Strengths

It Places Class at the Centre

Climate summits usually speak of "humanity", "future generations" and "stakeholders". In that language everyone is in the same boat; yet its owner, its captain and the person working in its engine room are different people. The Peoples' Climate Summit declaration breaks with this language. It connects the crisis to the capitalist mode of production, capital accumulation and corporate monopolies, and says the collective power of the working class is decisive. During the preparations, Ecehan Balta of the summit's international relations working group also said it proposed an anti-capitalist transformation. The text stands behind that claim.

It Does Not Restrict a Just Transition to Energy

For years, "just transition" has often been used narrowly, as if it meant moving a coal miner into solar-panel installation. The declaration widens the concept to include agriculture, mining, transport, waste management and care services. Including care work is particularly important. The reproductive labour capitalism renders invisible—caring for children, older people and sick people—takes a central place in this climate programme. The demand for the socialisation of care is valuable for the same reason.

A Workplace Demand: The Right to Stop Work in Dangerous Heat Without Loss of Pay

In our view, the text's strongest demand is the right to stop work in dangerous climate conditions without losing pay. It speaks directly to workers on construction scaffolding, in greenhouses and parcel depots, and on delivery motorcycles. "Climate justice" stops being an abstract concept and becomes a clause that can be written into a collective agreement. The declaration describes workers as decision-makers in the transition. This demand offers a practical way to give that description substance.

It Does Not Reduce the Public to State Ownership

The "Public Pathway" section does not define the public sphere solely as state ownership. It also includes public finance, democratic oversight, the participation of workers and service users, gender equality and accessibility. This is close to our questions: "in whose hands, under whose control and for whose benefit?" We know from the era of state economic enterprises that a state-owned business not controlled by workers and the public can also serve capital.

It Names Local Struggles

In the section on green extractivism, the declaration names struggles in Türkiye: Kazdağları, Akbelen, İliç, Develi, Varto and Diyadin. Its waste section also addresses shipbreaking in Aliağa. It states clearly that hosting the summit cannot make the country's ecological destruction invisible. The inclusion of İliç is particularly significant. In February 2024, the cyanide-bearing heap-leach landslide buried nine mine workers, showing that ecological destruction and workplace homicide can occur in the same event. Aliağa matters too: we recently wrote that the HABAŞ explosion there was not an accident but a mode of production. As we also know from Soma, death in a mine is a class issue.

It Sees Technology

Public oversight of water consumption by data centres and AI infrastructure, ecological limits and labour rights in critical-mineral extraction, transforming intellectual-property regimes: these subjects rarely appear together in a climate declaration. For those of us in tech labour who have discussed the AI bubble and the need to bring computing infrastructure under public control, these lines amount to a direct invitation to build an alliance.


At a Glance: What the Declaration Contains and What Could Be Developed

In the declarationWhat could be developed
The crisis is linked to the capitalist mode of production and capital accumulationFossil-capital ownership is not directly addressed; there is no demand to nationalise or socialise the companies
The working class is described as a "decisive force"No union or confederation is named, and there is no list of signatories
North–South inequality and debt cancellationThe concept of imperialism and Türkiye's intermediate position as an exporter of capital are not visible
Kazdağları, Akbelen, İliç and other local struggles are namedThe government carrying out these policies is not named; the Kurdish question appears only as "democratic peace"
The English written text calls for halting Akkuyu and cancelling SinopThe long Turkish written text has no nuclear section; the shorter declaration read aloud in Turkish opposed nuclear expansion
Criticism of COP mechanismsThe text still expects something from the Belém–Antalya Just Transition Mechanism
Comprehensive demands across many subjectsNo priorities, timetable, tasks or responsible organisations are specified
The right to stop work without loss of payThere is no workplace or collective-bargaining campaign plan

Six Comradely Notes on What Could Be Developed

If Capital Accumulation Is the Root Cause, Why Not Ask About Ownership?

The declaration makes the right diagnosis: the crisis arises from capital accumulation. But when it comes to the prescription, ownership is left unresolved. Public energy systems, cooperatives and community energy are sound proposals. Yet they do not by themselves change ownership of the existing energy monopolies. There is no explicit demand in the text for nationalisation or socialisation of the companies.

This is more than a stylistic choice. Unless fossil-fuel capital is dispossessed, a phase-out can take place only at the pace and on the terms capital permits. A coal plant closes and its owner receives compensation; the same holding company then builds a solar farm in its place. The worker is sent either to a retraining course or into unemployment. The capital group that cuts down olive groves in Akbelen may tomorrow present itself as a "green energy investor". As long as ownership remains in the same hands, cooperatives remain small islands beside monopolies.

Our proposal is to add an explicit demand for fossil-fuel companies and electricity distribution monopolies to be brought into public ownership under worker and community control. The observation that public provision is not simply state ownership is valuable. Its corollary is that public provision cannot skip the ownership question. As we wrote about the Liberation Declaration, the strength of a programme is measured by its courage in addressing ownership.

Why Is the Concept of Imperialism Absent?

The word "imperialism" does not appear in the declaration. Instead it uses the concepts of the Global South, exploitation, occupation and colonialism. North–South division is useful language for describing injustice. But it can obscure that capital moves between classes as well as countries. The North has workers too; the South has billionaires.

This gap matters even more for Türkiye. Türkiye is not only a country harmed by the climate crisis. Turkish construction, energy and mining capital makes major investments in Africa, Central Asia and the Caucasus. The declaration aims for the next meeting to be held in Ethiopia. That is a good aim. But if we go there without discussing the role of Turkish capital in the region, "South–South solidarity" will fail to see its own contradiction. The concept of imperialism lets us see that countries in an intermediate position, such as Türkiye, can be both exploited and exploiters.

Who Is Being Addressed: COP or the Streets?

The declaration is written against COP. It recalls the failures of previous summits—Copenhagen, Glasgow and Belém—and criticises carbon markets. Yet it also asks that the Belém–Antalya Just Transition Mechanism discussed at COP31 be more than a forum for exchanging information. That demand is understandable: the movement wants to monitor negotiations. Nevertheless, it creates uncertainty about the text's addressee.

Thirty years of COP experience are before us. Last year in Belém, a decision on phasing out fossil fuels did not enter the final text. These mechanisms do not bind capital because its representatives are not on the other side of the table; they sit at the table itself. Of course negotiations should be monitored and assessed. But a peoples' declaration should address above all workers in factories, fields and neighbourhoods, not negotiators. Its demands should reflect that choice: "we will organise this" rather than only "we ask COP for this".

Naming the Government and the Kurdish Question

The declaration criticises mining and energy policies rather than directly targeting the government of Türkiye. Its observation that hosting the summit cannot conceal destruction is important, but it does not say who carries out these policies. A particular government grants licences in Kazdağları, sends gendarmerie against villagers in Akbelen and approves environmental impact reports in İliç. That government also hosts COP31. Criticism that does not name its political addressee risks presenting those policies as impersonal and apolitical facts.

There is similar reticence on the Kurdish question. The word "Kurdish" does not appear; the text speaks only of "developing democratic peace in Türkiye". We understand the sensitivity and circumstances of the peace process. But the inclusion of Varto and Diyadin alone shows how ecological destruction and political pressure in the region are intertwined. Giving the demand for peace ecological and class content begins by not being afraid to name it.

Two Languages, Two Texts

We want to write this note carefully because it could easily turn into an unfair accusation. But overlooking it would not do justice to comradeship either.

The English version of the long written declaration includes a section on nuclear energy. It calls for "a halt to construction at Akkuyu" and cancellation of the Sinop project. The Turkish version we examined has no such section: the words "nuclear", "Akkuyu" and "Sinop" do not appear there. The English text also includes sections on the International Court of Justice's 2025 advisory opinion and the relationship between methane and livestock that are absent from the Turkish written version.

This matters because Akkuyu is one of the government's most important prestige projects and a symbol of its strategic relationship with Russia. The summit's own programme had also announced that the possibility of a nuclear-free life would be discussed. Nuclear opposition was therefore a position voiced at the summit.

Our observation concerns the long written versions only. In the shorter declaration read aloud in Turkish by Ecehan Balta on 18 November, a halt to nuclear expansion from Akkuyu to Sinop was explicitly demanded. Yeni Yaşam's report of the speech shows that this public position was also expressed in Turkish. The documents available to us do not explain the difference between the long written versions; it cannot be taken as proof of self-censorship. If a section was omitted during translation or final editing, the Turkish version can be completed. Consistency among a peoples' declaration's different versions matters.

We hope the summit assembly will explain the difference—not to accuse it, but to preserve the consistency of the text.

A Programme or a Statement of Position?

Palestine, water, food, waste, science, care, debt and energy are all important. But when a declaration asks for everything, it leaves nothing prioritised. The text has no concrete action timetable. Its only time reference is the goal of meeting again in Ethiopia next year. It calls for a democratic just-transition mechanism but does not describe how it would operate. There is no list of signatory organisations. It speaks in the name of workers, peasants, women, unions and scientists, but does not specify which union has committed to what. The word "unions" appears, but no confederation or union is named.

Describing the working class as the decisive force without naming any of its organisations is the text's central contradiction. A class becomes an actor through its organisations. An unorganised actor remains only a hope. As we argued in Organising 2.0, what can unite a fragmented working class is not declarations but shared workplace practices.


Three Questions for the Declaration

Let us ask the declaration the three questions we ask of every text.

In whose hands? According to the declaration, energy, water, land and seeds should be in society's hands. But it does not say in whose hands they are today or how they will be taken from them. The answer to the first question remains at the level of an aspiration.

Under whose control? This question receives the strongest answer: democratic oversight, participation by workers and users, and public finance. Here the text genuinely advances the discussion.

For whose benefit? For life, working people and future generations. But it leaves unstated whose interests must give way for that benefit to be secured. Every gain involves someone losing a privilege. Unless the privileges fossil-fuel capital must lose are named, "everyone's benefit" remains an abstraction.


Concrete Tasks

Turning the declaration into a programme is the task of its readers as well as its authors. We propose:

  • Make the right to stop work in dangerous heat a campaign. Together with unions in construction, agriculture, warehousing and delivery, put a clause on stopping work without loss of pay into draft collective agreements. Make data on heat-related deaths collected by workplace-death monitors the backbone of the campaign.
  • Connect ecology and workplace safety from İliç to Aliağa. Propose joint monitoring committees of environmental defenders and workers' organisations in mining and heavy-industry regions.
  • Add an ownership demand to the declaration. Propose that the next summit text call for fossil-fuel and electricity distribution monopolies to be brought into public ownership under worker and community control.
  • Complete the Turkish text. Ask the summit assembly to explain the difference between the written Turkish and English versions and add the nuclear section to the Turkish one.
  • Make unions signatories. Take the declaration to the executive boards of confederations and sectoral unions and create a list of signatories.
  • Monitor data-centre water and energy consumption. As tech workers, begin an open-data project tracking resource use by data centres operating or planned in Türkiye.
  • Go to Ethiopia with a dossier on Turkish capital. Prepare a report for the next meeting on the ecological and labour record of Turkish mining, energy and construction investments in Africa.

Dear Comrades,

There were two summits in Antalya. At one, states and companies discussed how capital would manage the crisis. At the other, peoples discussed who created the crisis and who pays for it. The second summit's declaration achieved class clarity in its diagnosis. That is no small achievement for Türkiye's ecological movement.

But diagnosis must be followed by a prescription. The prescription is ownership, organisation and priorities. The declaration says the collective power of the working class is decisive. We agree. What will make that power decisive is not declarations alone, but those texts becoming workers' own demands on a construction site, in a mine or in a warehouse.

We defend life and will rebuild the world. We will decide how to build that world together: through organisation and comradely debate.

In solidarity.


Related Posts

Newsletter