The Class Behind the Curtain: Morality That Bends for the Strong and Hardens against the Weak
Turkey's Map of Power in a Flat, through Özkan Çelik's Film Perde

Spoiler warning: This essay discusses the plot, the key scenes and the ending of "Perde" in detail. If you have not seen the film yet, we suggest you watch it first and read this afterwards.
At the Marmaris Film Days we watched Özkan Çelik's film Perde (The Curtain). When we left the hall, a single question stayed in our minds: Does a crime look for its perpetrator, or for the weakest shoulder that can carry its weight?
In the audience talk after the screening, the director said that what he wanted to tell in the film was not the question "why is the one in the right not seen?", but hypocrisy. This essay follows that sentence. We will read the film not as a piece of film criticism, but as an analysis of a society. Our question is this: If you are strong, why can you get clear of everything, and if you are weak, why do you pay the price even for what you did not do? And how is it that people who know everything can, at the end of the evening, quietly clear the table together?
First we will give a summary of the essay, then we will introduce the film, and then we will open each heading in detail.
Summary: Ten Theses
Perde draws the map of power of a block of flats, at a dinner table laid for a promotion party. A momentary look through a parted curtain turns into a caretaker wrongly accused, a manager who stays silent, a wife who knows the truth and draws back, and a circle of friends who, knowing everything, clear the table together. What the film shows us is not bad people one by one. It is a social fabric in which morality bends for the strong and hardens against the weak. We can summarise this fabric in ten theses:
- The film is not a story of victimhood. It is a mirror of hypocrisy. By the director's choice, the camera stays not on the one who suffers the injustice, but on those who sacrifice him. It does not give the audience an innocent to pity. It gives them their own face.
- Morality is not above classes. No one disputes the principle that "to watch someone is shameful". What is disputed is whom the principle will be applied to. The principle is universal, the application is a matter of class.
- Morality and ethics are not the same thing. In Ioanna Kuçuradi's distinction: morality is the changeable system of norms that holds in a community; ethics is the effort to judge a concrete situation, and the worth of a human being, correctly. The table speaks in morality. No one makes an ethical judgement.
- Suspicion flows downward, and charity reproduces the hierarchy. Evidence is not sought; the caretaker's class position takes the place of evidence. The old jacket Samet gives him makes two people look alike, but loads the guilt onto only one of them.
- The middle layer bows upward and presses downward; it lives its honesty only so long as the price can be paid. Samet stays silent to protect his promotion; Zeynep knows the truth, but surrenders to the morality of her class.
- Defending oneself is the most respectable cover for spending an innocent. No one is attacking Samet. Only his status is in danger. In the name of "looking after oneself", the price is transferred to an innocent. Because the means of defence are distributed unequally, this transfer is always downward.
- The victims are invisible. The accused caretaker is alone at the police station, and the voice of the woman who was watched is lost in her husband's theatre of "honour". The fate of both is in the hands of those at the table.
- When the flag covers the camera, the sacred becomes the shield of the crime. A flag hung on the block for a special day falls in front of the camera that could have recorded the truth. No one planned it; but the ritual itself drew a curtain. This is also what those who take refuge in the flag do in society.
- The table is cleared together. In the last scene, everyone, knowing everything, quietly and jointly cleans the table. Hypocrisy is not one person's problem. It is a problem of the social fabric. And indifference is not neutrality. It is taking the side of the strong. The film also leaves unanswered the hope that Samet will confess at the last moment; because that hope, too, is another happy ending that would comfort the audience.
- This is not the story of a single block of flats, and the way out is not in individual virtue. Calling it "the careless worker" in a workplace killing, "fate" in an earthquake, "the market" in a fraud, is the same mechanism at a large scale. What will make it expensive to spend an innocent is organised solidarity.
Now let us introduce the film, and then open these theses one by one.
Let Us Introduce the Film
Credits
- Film: Perde (IMDb)
- Director: Özkan Çelik (Babamın Kemikleri, My Father's Bones)
- Screenplay: Özkan Çelik and Cem Zeynel Kılıç
- Cast: Tülin Özen (Zeynep), Cem Zeynel Kılıç (Samet), İpek Türktan, Duygu Karaca, Bedir Bedir and others
- Genre and running time: Drama, black comedy; 84 minutes
- Release: 3 April 2026
- Awards: At the 32nd Adana Golden Boll Film Festival (2025), Best Screenplay, Best Actress (Tülin Özen), Best Supporting Actress (Duygu Karaca) and Best Supporting Actor (Bedir Bedir)
The Story
Samet is giving a dinner for his friends at home, to celebrate his promotion to general manager. Before he enters the building he feeds the cats in the garden. He is someone close to the title "a good man". That evening, through a parted curtain on the garden floor, he sees the woman next door undressing; for a moment their eyes meet, and Samet runs up to his flat.
A little later a noise breaks out in the block. The woman says that a man in a brown jacket and a white shirt, with a plastic bag in his hand, was watching her. This description fits both Samet and the caretaker who wears Samet's old clothes. No one dwells on Samet; the arrows turn straight onto the caretaker. And the security camera that could have recorded what happened has stayed behind a flag hung on the block for a special day.
As Mazlum Vesek's piece on Medyascope also underlines, the talk at the table comes, of itself, to the "peeping" incident in the block; the caretaker has been accused and taken to the police station. On one side a table raising glasses, on the other a worker trying to defend himself at the station. Samet's wife Zeynep slowly understands the truth, and comes up against a great dilemma. At the end of the evening, everyone, knowing everything, gets up and clears the table together.
The film has a structure close to theatre, moving almost in a single space, through dialogue. It deserves its awards; because the screenplay fits a society's moral account onto a dinner table without making grand speeches.
What Did the Director Want to Tell? Not Victimhood, Hypocrisy
The statement Özkan Çelik made in the audience talk at the Marmaris Film Days is the key to reading the film. The same story could have been told in two separate ways. In the first, the caretaker wrongly accused would have been at the centre of the camera: his fear, his helplessness at the station, his family's alarm. The film would ask us "why is the one in the right not seen?", and in the hall we would grieve for him. In the second, the camera stays at the table. The caretaker is almost never seen; what is seen are those who sacrifice him. Çelik chose the second road.
The narrative of victimhood has a trap: it comforts the audience. We grieve for the innocent who suffers an injustice, we feel ourselves on the right side as we leave the hall, we say "we would not have done this", and we go home with nothing changed. The narrative of hypocrisy does not give this comfort. It shows us people who feed the cats, who give their old clothes to the caretaker, who hold cultivated conversations at the table: people like us. The audience is forced to identify not with the caretaker, but with those at the table.
Bertolt Brecht built his theatre on "the alienation effect" for exactly this reason: he wanted the spectator not to be carried away by the hero and purged emotionally, but to take a distance from what they saw and to think. The single-space structure of Perde produces a similar effect. The film gives us not a victim, but a mirror.
For this reason, the caretaker and the woman who was watched being almost never seen is not a lack. It is a conscious choice. The caretaker's invisibility is itself how the table sees him. The question "why is the one in the right not seen?" does not disappear. It changes place: Why do we choose not to see? This essay follows the director's choice too; it puts its weight not on the victim, but on the table.
Whose Morality?
The Principle Is Universal, the Application Is a Matter of Class
One of the oldest arguments in the history of philosophy is exactly this film's question. In Plato's Republic, Thrasymachus claims that justice is "what is to the advantage of the stronger". Socrates tries to refute him, and for centuries standing on Socrates' side has been counted as what being moral requires. But after watching Perde, one cannot help asking: Might Thrasymachus be describing not what morality ought to be, but how it in fact works in a class society?
In The German Ideology, Marx and Engels give this question a historical answer: the ruling ideas of every age are the ideas of the ruling class. In Anti-Dühring, Engels takes one more step: every morality that has existed until today is, in the last analysis, a product of the economic condition of society, and within class antagonisms it has either justified the interest of the ruling class or given voice to the anger of the oppressed against this rule.
This does not mean that morality is an empty word. It says that morality has an objective social function. In the film, everyone shares the principle that "to watch someone is bad". What is argued is whom this principle will be applied to. If Samet looked, it was "by mistake", "for a moment", "without meaning to". If the caretaker looked, "it was obvious anyway". The same eye, the same curtain, the same moment. The only thing that differs is whom the eye belongs to.
The Class of Hypocrisy
Let us add a class reading to the director's emphasis. Hypocrisy is most often seen as a flaw of character. Yet hypocrisy is the necessary form that morality takes in a class society.
Why are two faces needed? Because the principle that is spoken and the interest that is protected do not hold together. When the morality said to hold for everyone ("to watch is shameful", "the guilty must be punished", "one must tell the truth") clashes with the class interest that is in fact protected (the promotion, the status, the home, the comfort), a person defends the principle with one face and protects their interest with the other. If principle and interest coincided, there would be no need for hypocrisy.
In The Communist Manifesto, Marx and Engels harshly expose the gulf between the lofty words the bourgeoisie speaks about the family, honour and morality, and the way these things actually work. In the seventeenth century La Rochefoucauld defined hypocrisy as the homage that vice pays to virtue. This definition explains Perde very well: those at the table do not deny the principles. They defend them out loud. Hypocrisy is the proof that the principle is still in force, but is carried only as a face.
Morality or Ethics? A Distinction from Ioanna Hoca
At this point we have to turn to Ioanna Kuçuradi, our teacher, whom we lost at the beginning of October. As we also stressed in the essay in which we told of her, one of Kuçuradi's most lasting contributions to intellectual life in Turkey is her careful separation of two concepts that everyday language mixes together: morality and ethics. To understand Perde, this distinction is a key.
Two Concepts, Two Separate Worlds
For Kuçuradi, morality is the system of value judgements that holds in a particular group, at a particular time; the various and changeable systems of norms that say what ought to be done and what ought not. She says that these must not be confused with ethical values, and that for this reason she prefers to call these unwritten systems of norms, in the plural, "moralities". This is what we mean when we say "morality has decayed", "national morality", "professional morality": the rules a community counts as valid.
Ethics, by contrast, is a discipline of philosophy, a field of knowledge. It is not memorising norms or applying them. It is trying to judge a concrete situation, a person, or an action correctly. At the centre of Kuçuradi's thought stands the distinction between "value" and "value judgement". A value judgement is a verdict that is ready-made, learned by heart, resting most often on interest or habit. Evaluation rests on understanding the situation itself. The measure of this evaluation is the worth of the human being; and human rights, in her words, are principles for the treatment of persons.
| Morality | Ethics |
|---|---|
| The system of value judgements that holds in a group | A field of knowledge resting on the worth of the human being |
| It changes with the community, the time, the class | It aims to grasp the concrete situation correctly |
| It works with ready verdicts: "The caretaker is suspect" | It asks the situation: Who looked, what happened, who was harmed? |
| It asks what is "valid" | It asks what is "right" |
| It shames and excludes the one who does not conform | It shows where human worth has been damaged |
| It speaks with the flag, with honour, with status | It speaks with principles for the treatment of persons, with human rights |
The Table Speaks in Morality
When we look at the film with this distinction, everything falls into place. Everyone at the table is extremely "moral". They find the watching shameful, they defend the woman's honour, they want the guilty punished. But all of them speak with ready value judgements: the caretaker is poor, so he is suspect; Samet is a manager, so he is respectable.
What is missing at the table is not morality. It is ethics. No one asks the situation itself; no one listens to what the caretaker did, where he was, what he said. The caretaker is condemned as a category before he is judged. In Kuçuradi's language, a person has not been evaluated; a value judgement has been stuck onto him. A human being taken to the station and cast out before he can defend himself is the textbook example of the violation of the principles for the treatment of persons: no presumption of innocence, no right of defence, no human worth.
Kuçuradi and Marx: A Dialogue
Here we have to be honest. Ioanna Hoca was not a Marxist, and she did not build ethics with the categories of class. Her project was a universal ethical grounding, against relativism, resting on the worth of the human being. The Marxist tradition, for its part, put its weight on explaining the class origin of moralities.
But these two approaches complete each other in front of Perde. Marx and Engels explain to us why the moralities in force carry the interest of the ruling class, and why suspicion flows downward. Kuçuradi gives the philosophical tool for distinguishing what is valid from what is right. The two meet at the same point: a norm that holds in a society is not right merely because it holds.
What we would add is this: as we will see in Zeynep's example below, knowing the right evaluation is not enough to put it into life. For ethical knowledge to be able to turn into ethical action, it depends on not having to pay the price of that action alone: that is, on material conditions and on organised solidarity. This is why we claim our teacher's philosophy of human rights from the perspective of the class struggle: not only to know human rights, but to make them real for everyone, and most of all for those who have no voice at the table.
The People at the Table: A Block of Flats' Map of Class
The Caretaker: Why Does Suspicion Flow Downward?
The most striking side of the film is that no one asks for evidence. The description fits two people, but the investigation turns onto one person, because the caretaker is socially seen as "fit to do this".
In Turkey this way of looking has a long history. Everyone who comes from the outskirts, who has migrated from the provinces, who has little education, who is "not one of us", is a potential criminal. When there is a theft, the first person questioned is the cleaner; the first person sought on the estate is the construction worker; the first person stopped in a police check on the street is the dark-skinned young man. This is not an individual prejudice. It is class inscribed on the body and on the place. As we tried to show in our essay on racism, the category of "the other" is always intertwined with a category of the labour market.
What Melvin Lerner called, in social psychology, "the belief in a just world" is at work here: people want to believe that the world is just, and they tend to think that what happens to those in a hard situation is "what they deserved". We discussed this mechanism in detail in Why Do We Deceive Ourselves?. The table in Perde is the belief in a just world turned into a dinner invitation: the caretaker is already poor, already outside, already suspect; if he were guilty as well, the order of the world would not break. But if Samet is guilty, what everyone at the table believes about themselves is shaken.
The Political Economy of the Old Jacket
One of the film's strongest images is the jacket the caretaker wears. Samet has given him his old clothes. A kindness; like feeding the cats, a part of being "a good man".
But that kindness also prepares the condition of the disaster. The clothes the woman describes fit both the one who gives and the one who receives. Charity makes two people look equal; but the equality stays only in the clothes. When the accusation comes, the one who gave the jacket is "the gentleman", and the one who wears the jacket is "the suspect".
Marcel Mauss had shown that the gift is never without a return, and that it sets up an obligation and a hierarchy between the giver and the receiver. Engels, too, in The Condition of the Working Class in England, criticises bourgeois charity harshly: the bourgeois first exploits the poor, then gives them alms for his own peace of mind, and in return expects the poor to stay out of his sight. The old jacket creates, on the caretaker's body, a disguise in which he can stand in for Samet. Charity here is a curtain covering over the class relation.
The matter of the cats is tied to the same logic. Mercy is generous so long as it is cheap. Giving food to a cat loses one nothing; telling the truth may cost the promotion, the status, the career. Samet's goodness is goodness so long as it has no price.
Samet: The Morality of the Cyclist
Samet is not a boss. He too works under someone's orders; the general managership is a step on the management floor of capital. But it is exactly this in-between position that explains the film's moral knot.
There is a likeness many writers have used since Heinrich Mann: "the cyclist type". He bows upward, and he pedals downward. Samet is weak against those above: his promotion is new and fragile; a suspicion of "harassment" can end his career. He is strong against those below: the caretaker wears his old clothes, and is paid a wage from the dues of people like him; with one word he can change the caretaker's life.
If Samet told the truth, perhaps everything would have settled. But he does not trust the reaction of the people around him. He knows the morality of his own class well: that morality is always ready to sacrifice the one below in order to save the one above. Samet is afraid that this morality might be applied to him too, and for this reason he applies it to the caretaker.
When we wrote on the poverty of the white collar, we told how the waged middle layers see themselves as separate from the working class, and yet become more and more precarious. Perde shows the moral result of this precariousness: someone who thinks they have something to lose can sacrifice someone who will lose still more, in order to protect it.
Zeynep: There Is Ethical Knowledge, There Is No Ethical Action
The moral centre of the film is not Samet. It is Zeynep. Tülin Özen's award-winning performance takes its meaning here. Through the film Zeynep is an honest character, one who says what she knows to be right. But the moment she sees the crime shining on her husband, she meets a choice: will she defend the truths she believes, or the security of her own life? And she looks for ways to move the crime away from her home.
Kuçuradi's distinction appears most sharply here. Unlike everyone at the table, Zeynep knows the situation; the first condition of ethical evaluation, that is, the correct grasp of the situation, is there in her. But the knowledge does not turn into action. Zeynep chooses not the road ethics shows, but the road the morality of her class shows. Morality asks what is valid, ethics asks what is right; when Zeynep is caught between the two, she surrenders to what is valid.
Brecht's famous line in The Threepenny Opera sums up this moment: first the belly is filled, then morality comes. What Brecht said was not that the hungry are immoral, but that morality cannot exist independently of material conditions. Zeynep is not hungry; but a promotion, a wage, an arrangement of life ties her too to a material account. The morality of the middle class really exists, and it is really defended at the table; but its test is given at the moment its price has to be paid out of one's own pocket. And most of the time it is lost in that test.
This does not make Zeynep a "bad character". It makes her a class subject. Let us recall the distinction Fromm drew between "having" and "being": the person who lives in the mode of having can betray their own values out of the fear of losing what they have. What Zeynep fears to lose is the home, the status, her husband's career. What she loses is herself.
Those at the Table: Cultural Capital Is Not a Conscience
The friends at the table are cultivated, educated people, "with their perceptions open". They probably defend equality, grow angry at injustices, share the right things on social media. But, in the apt observation of Banu Bozdemir's review on Beyazperde, under the table there is a darkness and a prejudice that swallows the facts.
With the concept of "cultural capital", Pierre Bourdieu had shown that education, taste and manner of speech are also instruments of class distinction. Cultural capital does not make a person more moral; it only gives the skill of justifying one's immorality more finely. Those at the table may not use coarse words when they accuse the caretaker; perhaps they say "the poor man" or "a victim of the system". But the result does not change: the load still goes downward.
Gramsci's concept of hegemony is useful here. The ruling order runs not only by force, but also by consent, and the firmest consent is the consent of people who think themselves progressive. As we discussed when we wrote on getting free from the language of hegemony, the table in Perde is a place where a language is spoken that looks polite, cultivated, empathic, and yet does not touch the class hierarchy even once.
The Unseen Woman: Whose Hands Hold the Victim's Voice?
The woman who was watched, the real victim of the incident, is almost never seen. Her husband comes forward in her name, fights, demands an account. This gap, too, is part of the director's choice to tell not victimhood but hypocrisy.
In the patriarchal order, a woman's body belongs not to herself but to her family, to her husband, to "honour". Being watched is perceived not as an attack on the woman's own privacy, but as a violation of the husband's property. As Engels showed in The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, with the birth of private property the woman too was turned into the object of a property relation. In Whose Family Is Safe? we discussed how the discourse of "the family" turns into an apparatus of control; in Perde we see the micro scale of the same apparatus. The woman has no voice, but the theatre of "honour" set up in her name is very successful at finding the weakest man to accuse.
There are two oppressed people in the film: the caretaker, accused because of his class, and the woman, whose voice is taken from her because of her sex. The fate of both is in the hands of the people at the table.
Spending the Innocent While Looking After Oneself
Perhaps the deepest layer of the film's moral knot is this: Samet and Zeynep do not see themselves as bad people. They see themselves as people who are defending themselves. And "defending oneself" is the strongest excuse a person can tell their conscience.
Defence When There Is No Attack
In law, the conditions of legitimate self-defence are clear: there must be an unjust attack, and the defence must be proportionate to that attack. In Perde, no one is attacking Samet; no one suspects him. What is in danger is not Samet's body or his freedom. It is his promotion, his status, his respectability at the table.
What is more, Samet's "defence" is directed not at an attacker, but at a third person who has nothing to do with the incident. This is no longer defence. It is a transfer of the cost. Samet takes the load that might fall on him and puts it on the shoulder that can most easily be made to carry it. Zeynep's moves work by the same logic: to move the crime away from the home is to carry the crime into someone else's home.
"I Had No Other Choice"
What Jean-Paul Sartre called "bad faith" is exactly this: a person's hiding their own freedom from themselves, presenting the choice they made as if it were a necessity. "I had no other choice", "I had to think of my family", "everyone would have done the same". These sentences are the way of handing the responsibility for the choice over to the conditions.
Yet Samet had a choice: to tell the truth. Perhaps he would have been ashamed, perhaps his promotion would have shaken; but no one would have lost their job, their home, their honour. The choice was not between two equal losses. It was between an embarrassment and the breaking of a life. To prevent his own embarrassment, Samet chose to spend someone else's life.
Kant's best-known principle of moral philosophy needs to be remembered here: never to see a human being merely as a means, but always at the same time as an end. The caretaker is turned into the means of Samet's salvation. In Ioanna Hoca's language, the human worth of one person is spent for the sake of another person's interest.
The Scapegoat: On Whose Back Does the Community's Peace Rest?
In his work on The Scapegoat, René Girard tells how communities solve their internal tensions: the anger and the suspicion that everyone could turn on everyone else are directed onto a single victim. When the victim is chosen, the community is relieved, and peace is set up again. Whether the victim is really guilty does not matter; what matters is that the community, unanimously, counts them guilty.
The table in Perde is a small stage of this mechanism. The block is in turmoil, the tension at the table is rising, and the tension has to flow somewhere. The moment the caretaker is chosen, the table is relieved, and the evening can go on. What the Marxist reading adds to Girard is this: the scapegoat is not chosen at random. It is always chosen from the lowest step of society, from among those who have the fewest means of defence.
The Unequal Distribution of the Means of Defence, and the Caretaker's Home
The "right" of self-defence looks equal for everyone. But the means of self-defence are not distributed equally.
Samet's word is believed, because he is a manager. Around him there are friends who trust him. He can express himself properly, he knows the right tone; if need be he hires a lawyer, he calls an acquaintance. And, most important, no one suspects him. The caretaker's word is not trusted. There is no one to stand surety for him. At the station he may not know what to say, or how; he has no money to hire a lawyer, no acquaintance to call.
And his home is tied to his job. As lawyers have noted, the allocation of housing to a caretaker is not obligatory; the flat that is allocated is a social right used for the duration of the job, and it must be vacated when the employment contract ends. Under the Condominium Ownership Law, a caretaker whose contract ends for any reason must vacate the dwelling within fifteen days. If the caretaker is accused, he loses not only his job but his home, perhaps his children's school, the order of his family. If Samet is accused, he loses his promotion. Both lose, but the weight of the losses is not the same.
In such a world, to say "let everyone defend themselves" is to apply an equal rule to an unequal ground. The result is clear: when everyone looks after themselves, the one who has no power to look after themselves is spent. In Turkey we see the large-scale examples of this every day. After a workplace killing, those who are tried are most often the foreman, the chargehand, the subcontractor's responsible person; the managers of the company that took no precaution, "while defending themselves", push the responsibility downward. When a scandal breaks in an institution, the first person sacrificed is the worker at the lowest grade. In all of them the same logic: the one above protects themselves, and the cost flows downward.
The Ideology of Defence in Our Language
This logic has settled into our language too. "Every sheep is hanged by its own leg." "May the snake that does not touch me live a thousand years." "A broken arm stays inside the sleeve." These sayings are passed from generation to generation like a knowledge of survival; but each of them is a piece of ideology that puts individual protection, or silence, in the place of solidarity. The ruling order reproduces itself most of all through these sayings, which even the oppressed take as natural.
In Leviathan, Thomas Hobbes saw self-preservation as the first law of nature, and described a world without a state as the war of all against all. It has often been said that what Hobbes told as the "state of nature" was in fact a portrait of the rising market society of his own age. In an order where competition determines everything, everyone's looking after themselves looks like a law of nature. But it is not a law of nature. It is the law of a particular social order.
The Counter-Principle: An Injury to One Is an Injury to All
Against this logic stands a principle of the workers' movement, more than a century old: an injury to one is an injury to all. The principle is simple, but it is revolutionary; it puts collective defence in the place of individual defence.
If there had been a union beside the caretaker, a solidarity network of building caretakers, a legal support, Samet's account would have changed too. The innocent is spent because they are easy to spend. When spending them becomes hard, the strong one too is forced to look for ways of telling the truth. To build an organisation that makes it expensive to spend the innocent, instead of leaving morality to individual heroism: this is exactly the contribution of the class struggle to morality.
When the Flag Covers the Camera
One of the images in the film that most needs to be thought about, perhaps the quietest, is this: the only impartial witness that could have recorded what happened, the security camera, stays behind a flag. This flag was not put there to cover a crime. It was hung on the block on the occasion of a special day; one of the flags that, on every holiday, on every day of commemoration, decorate the fronts of thousands of blocks of flats in Turkey. But it has fallen exactly in front of the camera that could have seen what happened. The eye that could have shown the truth is closed by the nation's most sacred symbol.
No One Planned It, Everyone Benefited
The importance of this detail is that there is no conspiracy. The flag is part of a ritual in which the block shows itself collectively: a way of saying "we too are of this nation, we too are celebrating this day". The cover-up is born not of a malicious plan, but of this ritual that looks innocent.
Ideology, too, most often works exactly like this. A conspiracy is not needed every time, in order to cover the crimes of the ruling order. The rituals, the slogans, the sacred symbols that everyone joins in sincerely draw a curtain of themselves. No one plans it; but the side that benefits from staying behind the curtain is always the same. As Marx said of fetishism, people do not know this, but they do it.
There is one more irony. In Turkey, hanging the flag on blocks of flats on special days most often falls to the caretaker. The hand that carries the nation's symbol onto the building, and the shoulder that pays the price of the truth that symbol covers, belong to the same class.
In Whose Favour Is the Absence of the Record?
If the camera had seen, the argument would have ended. Who looked, who ran, who had the bag in their hand, would have stood in the recording. But there is no recording, and the absence of the recording does not produce the same result for everyone: the absence of evidence protects the strong and condemns the weak. For Samet, to say "there is no image" is to say "I am innocent"; for the caretaker, it is "you cannot clear yourself".
What is more, no one can remove the obstacle in front of the camera. You can draw a curtain, you can push a box; but the one who reaches for the flag is no longer the one seeking the truth. They become "the one who disrespects the flag". The untouchability of the sacred turns into the untouchability of the crime.
Ioanna Hoca's distinction is at work here too. The flag hung on a special day is the symbol of a community's common morality, of what we call "national morality". The camera is the instrument that could carry the first condition of ethics, that is, the knowledge of the situation. In the film, the symbol of morality closes the way in front of the knowledge of ethics. What is valid covers what is right.
Surveillance Always Looks Downward
Whom do the cameras in blocks of flats, on estates, in factories watch in everyday life? The caretaker, the cleaner, the courier, the worker. In The Card Around Our Necks we told how every step of the worker in the factory is put on record. Surveillance technology, in a class society, is set up to look downward. In Perde, the camera goes blind at the moment it could, for the first time, have recorded the one above. The eye never closes on the weak; on the strong, something is always found to close it.
Those Who Take Refuge in the Flag
There is a famous sentence reported as said by Samuel Johnson in 1775: patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel. Johnson was not belittling love of country; he meant the false patriots who make patriotism a shield for their own interests. We all know how this shield is used in Turkey:
- Corruption and fraud. When an investigation comes close to those who hold power, the matter turns all at once into a question of "national security"; those who demand an account are accused of "falling for the game of foreign powers". The sticking of the label of "treason" onto journalists who questioned the fund crisis was also the background of what we wrote on the fund fraud.
- Journalism. The "camera" that records the truth is most often the journalist. The easiest way to silence them is to define their report as an attack on the nation.
- The strike. In Turkey, strikes have been postponed again and again on the grounds of "national security" and "public health". The worker's organised voice was cut by a decision hiding behind the flag.
- Tenders and rent. The label "domestic and national" is spread like a cover over many projects kept clear of audit. The brighter the label, the harder it is to look underneath.
In all of them the mechanism is the same: the flag is stretched in front of the truth, and the one who seeks the truth is declared the enemy of the flag.
Whose Is the Flag?
Care is needed here. What we criticise is not the flag. It is the seizure of the flag.
Under this flag, poor peasants and workers fought in the National Struggle. The generation of 1968 voiced the demand for full independence with this flag. A symbol takes its meaning from the struggle of the people who carry it. The ruling class takes that meaning, turns it inside out, and covers it over its own crime.
This is the class function of nationalist ideology: to show the boss and the worker, the one who takes the tender and the subcontracted worker who dies in a workplace killing, as if they were equal under "a single nation". The block of flats in Perde shows how this equality works: the same flag, in the same building, covers one person's crime while leaving the other defenceless. The flag is everyone's; but the shield is only one person's. When Marx and Engels said in The Communist Manifesto that "the workers have no country", what they meant was not that workers do not love their country, but that the country has been taken from their hands. When we wrote on the law of the Republic, we discussed how the rising new nationalism covers the class agenda; the flag in Perde is a single frame in which the symbol of the nation covers the crime of the class.
The flag should fly not in front of the truth, but in the hands of those who seek the truth.
The Last Scene: Clearing the Table Together
Perhaps the film's harshest criticism is hidden in its quietest scene. The evening ends. The truth is now in front of everyone at the table; who looked, who was accused, whose life is breaking, all of it is known. And these people get up and, quietly, together, clear the table. The plates are carried to the kitchen, the leftovers are cleaned, the glasses are taken away. No one shouts, no one slams the door and leaves, no one says "this is wrong".
Cleaning Not the Evidence, but the Conscience
Clearing the table is one of the most ordinary jobs of everyday life, and the film uses exactly this ordinariness. The cleaning of the table is the cleaning of the incident. Together with the dirty plates, the dirt of the evening is carried to the kitchen, washed, and put on the shelf.
What catches the eye is that this is done jointly. One takes the plates, one folds the cloth, one sees to the washing up. This is a bitter picture of the only form of solidarity the middle class knows: the solidarity of being a partner in one another's silence. We tell solidarity as the oppressed giving a shoulder to one another; at the table in the film, solidarity turns into the privileged spreading a cover together over a crime. No one says "let us stay silent"; there is no need. Everyone knows what they will lose, and the silence sets itself up of its own accord, like an unspoken contract. As the flag closes the camera without planning it, the table too is cleared without planning.
Indifference Is Not Neutrality
In a short text he wrote in 1917, months before the October Revolution, Antonio Gramsci says that he hates the indifferent. For him, indifference is the dead weight of history; most of what happens happens not because a few people wanted it, but because the majority shrugged. The indifferent person is the silent partner of every evil that has been done.
The people clearing the table are not doing evil; they are only doing nothing. But in a class society, to do nothing is to take the side of the strong. If we return to Ioanna Hoca's distinction: indifference is the last form of giving up evaluation. A value judgement at least gives a verdict; indifference does not even feel the need to give a verdict. The situation is known, but it is not weighed. There is knowledge, there is no responsibility.
The Violence of Politeness
The reason this scene is so disturbing is that the violence is never seen. No one hits anyone, no one insults anyone; everything is polite, calm, civilised. But a person's job, home and honour are taken off the table as the price of this civilised evening.
The essence of middle-class hypocrisy is here: not a coarse tyranny, but an indifference set inside politeness. In Theodor W. Adorno's observation in Minima Moralia, a right life cannot be lived inside a wrong life. Clearing the table with care, hosting the guest well, keeping the home clean: none of these changes the fact that that home is protected at the price of someone else's life.
The Confession I Expected: Another Happy Ending
I need to set down a personal note here. Through the film, and especially as the last scene approached, I expected a release. I thought that at some point Samet would not be able to bear it, would get up from the table, would take an honest stand against all that shamelessness, and would confess what had happened. Most of all, in the face of Zeynep's turning back. After seeing that his wife, who defends the truth through the film, draws back the moment the crime touches her own home, I hoped that perhaps Samet would be ashamed and stand up, and say "it was me". It did not happen. The table was cleared.
After leaving the hall I began to think about this expectation itself. Because the expectation of a confession is also an expectation of a happy ending; only a more refined form of it. Above, we spoke of why the director did not choose the narrative of victimhood: grieving for the innocent comforts the audience. The confession does the same work, and more strongly. If Samet had said "it was me", all of us in the hall would have taken a deep breath. We would have seen that conscience wins in the end, that the good person is still alive somewhere inside, that the order can correct itself, and we would have left the hall lightened.
Aristotle calls this lightening katharsis, that is, purgation. Brecht's theatre was built exactly against this purgation: if the spectator is purged in the hall, nothing remains to be changed outside. At the end of The Threepenny Opera, Brecht openly mocks this expectation. As Mackie is going up to the gallows, the queen's mounted messenger arrives, brings the pardon, and on top of it ties on a castle and an income for life. Brecht puts this ridiculous happy ending on the stage to remind us that, in real life, mounted messengers hardly ever come. In the last scene of Perde, the mounted messenger does not come. Its not coming is the most honest thing the film does to the audience.
The expectation of a confession has a class content too. This expectation assumes that salvation will again come from above: the caretaker's fate depends on when Samet's conscience will wake. In this scenario too, the caretaker is not the subject of his own story. He is the one who waits; his being cleared is the favour of the strong. This is the moral counterpart of the old jacket: just as Samet gave his old clothes, one day he might also "give" the truth. But justice given as a favour does not break the hierarchy. It reproduces it. Even if Samet confessed, the decision would still have been in his hands.
What is more, in real life the confession rarely comes in this form. We hardly ever see a boss come out of his own accord after a workplace killing and say "I am responsible". Where the truth comes out, what brings it out is most often not an awakening of conscience; it is the families who follow the case with persistence, the lawyers who gather the documents, the journalists who keep the record, and the organised workers. Those who, after the explosion at HABAŞ, put the names, the numbers and those responsible on record one by one were they too.
This is why Zeynep's turning back is the key point of the film. The film shows us not whether conscience exists, but how long conscience can hold out against the price. If even the most honest character draws back when the price comes to the door of their home, to expect a confession from Samet of his own accord is to expect a miracle from the order. The line Brecht has spoken in Life of Galileo finds its place here: unhappy not the land that has no hero, but the land that needs a hero. If an innocent's salvation is left to one man's last-minute confession, the problem is larger than that man's conscience.
Even so, one should not be ashamed of this expectation. The expectation of a happy ending is born of a feeling that knows justice ought to be, and this feeling is valuable. The problem is not in the expectation itself, but in its address. It has to be taken from Samet's conscience and carried to the place it belongs, to organised solidarity. By not giving the confession, the film leaves this work to us: instead of waiting for the confession at the head of the table, to stand beside the caretaker. Perhaps the film's real ending is that unmet expectation which stays inside us as we leave the hall. The curtain closes, but the account does not close.
A Problem of the Fabric: Not One Person's, the Routine of an Order
This scene takes the film out of being an individual moral story and turns it into a problem of the social fabric. If only Samet had stayed silent, this would have been one person's cowardice. But everyone knows, and everyone clears the table. The problem is not in a single rotten thread. It is in the weave of the cloth.
The last scene of Perde shows us the face of this normalisation: not malicious, but tired; not cruel, but comfortable; not planned, but accustomed. And for exactly this reason, the hardest to change.
Above and Below: Two Moralities, One Order
When we set the situations of the two men in the film side by side, everything we have said gathers in a single table:
| Samet (Above) | The Caretaker (Below) |
|---|---|
| The description fits him, but no one dwells on him | The description fits him, and he is accused at once |
| His behaviour is counted "momentary", "by mistake" | His behaviour is counted "it was obvious anyway" |
| His kindness (the old jacket) makes him "a good man" | The kindness he received (the old jacket) makes him suspect |
| At the table, among his friends | At the police station, alone |
| He "defends himself" even when there is no attack | He is really accused, but his defence is not listened to |
| The means of defence are in his hands: word, status, circle | He is stripped of the means of defence: neither a surety nor a lawyer |
| What he will lose is a promotion | What he will lose is the job, the home and the order of the family |
| The camera's being blind protects him | The absence of evidence leaves him defenceless |
| The evening ends, the table is cleared together | His life breaks, and no one puts it back together |
| Morality bends for him | Morality hardens against him |
This table is not only the film's. It is Turkey's.
From the Block of Flats to the Country: The Large Scale of the Same Mechanism
The power of Perde is that it shows a large mechanism through a small incident. We have seen this mechanism in different forms in many essays we wrote this year.
In workplace killings. When a factory explodes, the first thing said is "an accident", the second is "the worker's carelessness". As we wrote on the explosion at HABAŞ, this is not an accident. It is a mode of production. But the guilt is loaded onto the one at the very bottom; the next day production goes on, and the table is cleared.
In earthquakes. The person responsible for the collapsed building is declared "fate". Those who passed the zoning amnesty, who gave the permit, who loosened the inspection and who shared the rent go on sitting at the table.
In financial frauds. As we saw when we wrote on the fund fraud and the crack in the spine: those who got out in time with inside information are protected, and the small investor pays "the risk of the market".
In journalism. The one who writes the report is arrested, and the powerful who are the subject of the report are protected. The one who shows the truth is punished.
In all of them there is the same structure: if the strong make a mistake, this is a misfortune; even if the weak make no mistake, this is their nature. Let us recall Anatole France's famous mockery: the law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich and the poor alike to sleep under bridges and to steal bread. The young Marx's essays on wood theft, written in 1842 in the Rheinische Zeitung, say the same thing: the poor peasants' gathering of branches that had fallen to the ground in the forest had been declared "theft", in line with the interest of the owners of the forest. When the property owner's interest turns into the language of the law, the life of the poor turns into a crime.
Why Is "If You Are Strong, You Get Away with It" So Widespread?
In Turkey, "if you are strong, you get away with it" is not a subject of mockery. It is a knowledge of life. Even if we do not say it to our children, they learn it with their eyes. This widespreadness has three sources. Economic: capitalism rests on competition; in competition the winner wins at the loser's expense, and this logic seeps from the market into everyday relations. Political: in an order where the judiciary works according to closeness to power, to hold power means, concretely, impunity; the rules are for the weak. Ideological: the ruling ideology presents poverty as individual failure and wealth as individual success; the strong person's slipping clear of the rules is counted "clever", and the weak person's being caught by the rules is counted "incompetence". As we wrote on the consent of labour, domination grows strongest when the oppressed internalise this way of looking.
But here there is also a contradiction that is the source of hope. As the knowledge that "if you are strong, you get away with it" spreads, the knowledge that this order is not just spreads too. People see the hypocrisy; like the audience in the film, they know who is guilty and who is accused. The question is whether this knowledge will turn into anger, into hopelessness, or into an organised power.
Does the System Dirty Everyone?
One of the film's brave sides is that it shows none of its characters as purely bad or purely good. Samet is not a monster. He is a cowardly man. Zeynep is not a traitor. She is a woman who is squeezed. Those at the table are not malicious. They are people who do not question their prejudices.
As Marx said in The Eighteenth Brumaire, people make their own history, but not under conditions of their own choosing. Samet's fear, Zeynep's choice, the friends' prejudice are the product of an order. But this does not remove individual responsibility; on the contrary, it sharpens it. For someone who knows the structure of the order, to say "I too am a victim of the conditions" cannot be an excuse.
The system's greatest success is to make everyone a little bit of an accomplice. The middle layers take small shares from the order, and these shares make them the guardians of the order. The old jacket, the cat food, the promotion party: all of them are small shares. And those small shares are paid as the price of turning a blind eye to a great injustice.
What Is the Curtain?
The film's name carries many meanings, and all of them meet the class reading.
The curtain of privacy. The curtain that separates the woman's room from the outside world. Privacy is a right; but whose right it is protected for is a question of class. The caretaker's privacy, in the caretaker's flat, in front of everyone's eyes, is no one's concern.
The curtain of the truth. The curtain Samet and Zeynep draw over their own eyes in order not to see their own crime. The curtain of ideology; the dark room Marx called the "camera obscura", which shows the truth upside down.
The curtain of the flag. The flag hung for a special day and fallen in front of the camera; perhaps the thickest curtain. Because you can part the other curtains, but to touch this curtain is counted "disrespect".
The curtain of the stage. Everyone at the table is playing a role: the good friend, the moral wife, the successful manager, the open-minded intellectual. The curtain closes as the table is cleared; what remains are the interests under the roles, and a spotless table.
The curtain of the cinema. And finally, the white screen that shows us this story. The task of art is perhaps exactly this: to part the curtain we draw in everyday life in order not to see.
Concrete Tasks
It is easy to watch the film, say "how realistic", and pass on. But this film also reminds us of some concrete tasks.
- Make the unseen workers visible. Building caretakers, estate security workers, cleaning workers, couriers: to speak of the working conditions, the housing precariousness and the lack of union organisation of people who live in the same building and are never seen.
- Put the security of caretakers' housing on the agenda. Fifteen days is not enough for a family to build its life again. That the right to housing is tied this tightly to the employment contract leaves the worker open to every kind of accusation and pressure.
- Make it expensive to spend the innocent. To build legal support networks and union organisation for those who are most easily sacrificed; to carry the principle "an injury to one is an injury to all" into everyday life.
- Defend evaluation in place of the value judgement. The plainest, and the hardest, task our teacher Ioanna left us: before speaking about a human being, ask the situation. Who, what did they do, what is the evidence, whose worth is being damaged?
- Change the language at the table. To object, at a table of friends, to sentences that begin "it was definitely him", is one of the everyday forms of the class struggle.
- Give the victim's voice back to the victim. Not to turn a violation a woman has suffered into a theatre of honour by the men who speak in her name; to put the woman's own testimony at the centre.
- Object to sacred symbols being made into a shield. Wherever an investigation, a report, a strike is silenced with the language of "national security" or "treason", to say to those who stretch the flag in front of the truth: "the flag is not your shield".
- Do not clear the table. After a workplace killing, a wrongful accusation, a corruption, not to allow the subject to be closed with "life goes on"; to follow the cases, to keep the commemorations going, to keep the record of what they want forgotten.
- Watch films together, discuss them together. Local events such as the Marmaris Film Days are the ground of these discussions. We also took the most important clue of this essay from the director himself, in the audience talk after the screening.
Dear Young Comrades
Perde shows us Turkey in a flat and at a dinner table. But those sitting at that table are not only Samet, Zeynep and their friends. As the director said in the audience talk in Marmaris, the film tells us not why the one in the right is not seen, but hypocrisy. That is, us. All of us are at that table from time to time: in the moments when, knowing who is guilty, we remain spectators of who will be accused. In the moments when, looking after ourselves, we do not ask on whom the price is being charged. And in the moments when, knowing everything, we help to clear that table quietly at the end of the evening.
In a class society, morality bends for the strong and hardens against the weak. When it is needed, even sacred symbols are made into the shield of the strong; the flag is stretched in front of the camera that would record the truth. This is not a fate. It is an order. And like every order, it can be changed. But the change is possible not by the Zeyneps, one by one, passing the test of conscience, or by a Samet's last-minute confession, but by the building of an organised power that will stand beside the caretaker, hear his voice, and share his loneliness.
As Ioanna Hoca reminded us, what is valid is not always what is right. Philosophy asks us what morality ought to be; class consciousness asks why that morality is not realised, and how it can be. Without the first, the second is without direction; without the second, the first stays powerless.
Parting the curtain is not enough. The room behind the curtain has to be turned into a just place for everyone who lives in that room.
For better days, all of us together.
Our Related Essays
- Telling Young Comrades about Ioanna Kuçuradi — our teacher's thought and legacy
- Why Do We Deceive Ourselves? — the belief in a just world, and the class of reason
- On Getting Free from the Language of Hegemony — the settling of prejudice in language
- The Consent of Labour — the reproduction of domination by consent
- From Having to Being — Fromm, and the fear of losing
- The Poverty of the White Collar — the precariousness of the middle layers
- What Is This Thing Called Racism? — the class content of the category of "the other"
- Whose Family Is Safe? — the discourse of "the family" turning into an apparatus of control
- The Card Around Our Necks — surveillance always looking downward
- Whose Law Is the Republic's Law? — the new nationalism covering the class agenda
- The Explosion at HABAŞ — the loading of guilt onto the very bottom
- Six and a Half Trillion and Whose Party Is the Fund Crisis Breaking? — the protection of those on the inside
Sources
The film and the reviews
- Audience talk with Özkan Çelik, Marmaris Film Days, November 2026
- Beyazperde — Perde (2026) film page
- IMDb — Perde
- Banu Bozdemir, "Perdeye dolananlar!" (Those tangled in the curtain), Beyazperde
- Mazlum Vesek, "Açık 'Perde' neyi anlatır?" (What does an open Perde tell?), Medyascope, 27 September 2025
- Artdog İstanbul — the Golden Boll 2025 awards
The legal situation of caretakers
- Problems concerning the caretaker in condominium ownership
- Emlak Kulisi — Is it obligatory to give a caretaker housing?
Ioanna Kuçuradi
- Ioanna Kuçuradi, İnsan ve Değerleri (The Human Being and Their Values), Turkish Philosophical Society Publications; Etik (Ethics), Turkish Philosophical Society Publications
- Ioanna Kuçuradi, "Eğitimi Yeniden Düşünmek" (Rethinking Education), Hacettepe University
- Ioanna Kuçuradi, "Laiklik ve İnsan Hakları" (Secularism and Human Rights), Journal of the Union of Turkish Bar Associations, issue 52, 2004
- Arzu Kök, "Ioanna Kuçuradi'nin Ardından" (After Ioanna Kuçuradi), Ulus Gazetesi
Theoretical background
- Plato, The Republic, Book I (the Thrasymachus argument)
- Aristotle, Poetics (katharsis)
- Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, The German Ideology (1846); The Communist Manifesto (1848)
- Friedrich Engels, The Condition of the Working Class in England (1845); Anti-Dühring (1878); The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884)
- Karl Marx, the wood-theft essays in the Rheinische Zeitung (1842); The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852)
- Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan (1651)
- François de La Rochefoucauld, Maxims (1665)
- Samuel Johnson's remark on patriotism (1775), James Boswell, The Life of Samuel Johnson (1791)
- Immanuel Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785)
- Antonio Gramsci, "The Indifferent" (La Città Futura, February 1917); Prison Notebooks
- Marcel Mauss, The Gift (1925)
- Bertolt Brecht, The Threepenny Opera (1928); Life of Galileo (1939); his writings on epic theatre and the alienation effect
- Jean-Paul Sartre, Being and Nothingness (1943)
- Theodor W. Adorno, Minima Moralia (1951)
- Erich Fromm, To Have or to Be (1976)
- Pierre Bourdieu, Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste (1979)
- Melvin Lerner, The Belief in a Just World (1980)
- René Girard, The Scapegoat (1982)
This essay was published on Knowledge Commons. The readings of the film are ours; the details of the plot are taken from the film itself, from the audience talk at the Marmaris Film Days, and from the reviews cited. You may reproduce it under the CC BY-SA 4.0 licence, with attribution. Reproduce it.









