Whose Language Is Mathematics?
How Does a Teacher Make a Student Love Mathematics, and How Do We Tell Everyone the Value of Mathematics?

This essay was born of a conversation. While speaking with Baki Hoca, a professor who trains mathematics teachers, the talk turned and turned, and it always came to the same question: How does a teacher make a student love mathematics? What answer does one give to a child who asks, "What use will this be to me, teacher?" And the larger question: How do we tell the real value of mathematics in our lives not only to the children in the classroom, but to the millions who left the examination behind long ago and who, years ago, banished themselves from this world with the sentence "I am not the quantitative type"?
What stood out in the conversation with Baki Hoca was that making mathematics loved is not a trick, a technique of presentation, or a matter of colourful slides. Mathematics is not a medicine that has to be dressed up in order to be loved. It is loved of itself at the moment it belongs to the child, explains the child's life, and strengthens the child. This essay is built on that conversation, and it takes one further step: it treats the question of making mathematics loved as a class question. Because in Turkey the relation a child forms with mathematics is determined, to a great extent, by the neighbourhood the child was born in, by the work the mother and the father do, and by whether there is a desk for study at home.
The conversation did not close there. Baki Hoca asked what makes mathematics difficult and terrifying when it is no different from the games children play while enjoying themselves, and what the teacher's role is in this, especially in the primary school. He asked why the student who succeeds in mathematics mostly appears successful in the other subjects too. And he asked this: Is doing mathematics serious work, or is it enjoyment itself?
The Summary First: Twelve Theses
1. We are not afraid of mathematics; we are judged by mathematics. The anxiety children in Turkey feel towards mathematics arises less from mathematics itself than from the use of mathematics as a tool of elimination and ranking. In PISA 2022, Turkey ranked first in mathematics anxiety.
2. "A head for mathematics" is a myth, and this myth has a class function. To tie success to an inborn talent naturalises inequality. In Turkey the mathematics average of children in the wealthiest quarter is at the level of Switzerland, while those in the poorest quarter remain at the level of Moldova. The difference between them is not in the head. It is at the table, in the room, and in the wallet. The oppressed person's belief in their own "lack of talent" is the maintenance of inequality by consent, not by force. In Gramsci's language, it is hegemony.
3. Mathematics was born of labour. The Egyptian who remeasured the fields after the Nile flood, the Babylonian mason who calculated the mortar, the algebra of Harezmi (al-Khwarizmi) dividing an inheritance, the merchant's ledger: mathematics is the abstracted mind of humanity's productive activity. To tell this to the child is to give mathematics back to the child.
4. Mathematics has two faces. The same mathematics both holds the bridge up and measures the worker's every movement on Taylor's stopwatch; it both calculates the dose of a vaccine and pushes the poor into a spiral of debt with a credit score. The student has to be shown these two faces together.
5. The first step in making it loved is to break the fear. The mistake is part of learning. A wrong answer is not a crime to be punished; it is the trace of thinking. The logic of "three wrongs cancel one right" is the logic of the elimination system, not the logic of learning.
6. One has to start from life and return to life. The minimum wage and the food basket, the tier on the electricity bill, the rise in rent, two different inflation figures: a problem that comes out of the student's life awakens far more curiosity than the pool-and-taps problem in the textbook.
7. Mathematics is not only useful; it is beautiful. The opening of a proof, the appearance of a pattern, the finding of an answer to the question "why?" is a pleasure proper to the human being. To count this pleasure as belonging only to an elite is also a class stance.
8. Proof is a democratic act. In mathematics a thing is true not because authority said it, but because it can be shown. To teach a child the idea of proof is to teach the child not to submit blindly to any authority.
9. Mathematics is learned through solidarity. Thinking together, group work, and explaining among peers, in place of competitive ranking: as Vygotsky said, what the child can do with someone else today, the child does alone tomorrow.
10. Mathematics is a commons, and it belongs to everyone. Euclid's proofs are no one's property. In the age of artificial intelligence, mathematical literacy is the precondition of being able to audit algorithms, statistics, and budgets. To give mathematics back to the people is to give reason back to the people.
11. Our curiosity will never end, and the language of that curiosity is mathematics. From Eratosthenes's calculation of the Earth's circumference from the shadow of a stick to Voyager's forty-nine-year journey, humanity's curiosity about the sky and about the future has always travelled by mathematics. Carl Sagan's "pale blue dot" reminds us both of our smallness and of our responsibility towards one another. The right to look at the stars, and the right to be curious about the future, is also a class matter.
12. Mathematics is a game, and the game is serious work. It is not something separate from the game children play while enjoying themselves. What makes it difficult and terrifying is not the rule itself. It is the order that, beginning in the primary school, takes the game out of the child's hands and puts time, the mark, and elimination in its place. At that moment the teacher either keeps the door of the game open or becomes the first guard of the fear. That the one who succeeds in mathematics also appears successful in the other subjects is not an inborn secret. Mathematics teaches a person to set up a problem, to follow a reason, and to audit a result. The conditions of the same table, the same room, and the same wallet spread across all the subjects at once.
Let us now open these theses one by one.
We Are Not Afraid of Mathematics; We Are Judged by It
What Do the Figures Say?
Let us look at the table first. In PISA 2022, the examination the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) administers to 15-year-old students, Turkey's mathematics average was 453 points: 39th place among 81 countries. On the six-level proficiency scale this score corresponds to the second level from the bottom. That is, our average student has mathematics skill only at the basic level. (haber.sol.org.tr) According to the assessment of the Education Reform Initiative, in Turkey nearly one child in three does not have basic proficiency in mathematics, and Turkey is among the countries where students' mathematics anxiety is high. (bianet) More striking still: Turkey ranked first in students' mathematics anxiety. (AA)
The picture does not change in the examination for passage to high school. According to what examination guides report from the statistics of the Ministry of National Education, the average on the LGS is only 5 to 6 net correct answers out of 20 questions in mathematics. (rehberpanda) About a million children sit this examination every year. In 2026 the number of students who sat it exceeded 994 thousand. (tahtaapp) An examination in which a million fourteen-year-old children cannot, on average, do three quarters of the mathematics questions says something about the children, and just as much about the order that set up that examination.
Where Does the Anxiety Come From?
Mathematics anxiety is often told as an individual problem: "the child's self-confidence is low", "the foundation is weak", "there is a lack of attention". Yet if anxiety is this widespread in a country, it is no longer the product of children one by one. It is a product of the system.
In Turkey, mathematics enters the child's life first as a tool of elimination. In the LGS, in the YKS, and in the KPSS, the subject that distinguishes most, and that "eliminates" most, is mathematics. When the child meets mathematics, what is offered is not a field of curiosity. It is a door. Behind that door stand a good high school, a good university, a good profession: in short, a good life. The child who cannot pass through the door is stamped, at the age of fourteen, with "you are not the quantitative type".
In this situation mathematics anxiety is in fact anxiety about the future. The child is not afraid of an equation. The child is afraid of how to face the family if the equation cannot be solved, and of being unable to get out of poverty. In our Education Dossier (Our Education Dossier Is Out: Whose School Is It?) we discussed in detail that the school is a class institution. The mathematics lesson is the sharpest sorting machine of this class institution.
Is There Such a Thing as "a Head for Mathematics"?
We have all heard it: "that one has a head for mathematics", "our child is on the verbal track", "girls do not like mathematics". These sentences look innocent, but they perform a deep ideological function. If you tie success in mathematics to an inborn talent, you have also tied failure to an inborn lack. Social inequality then looks like a natural event.
The figures tell another story. According to PISA 2022, in Turkey the mathematics average of students in the top socioeconomic quarter is 502, while the average of those in the bottom quarter is 420. The children of the wealthiest families are around the Swiss average, and the children of the poorest families are around the Moldovan average. (haber.sol.org.tr) When one looks at types of school, the gulf deepens further: an average of 598 in science high schools, 395 in vocational and technical Anatolian high schools. The Education Reform Initiative calculates this difference as a distance equal to about ten school years. (bianet)
This difference of more than a hundred points is not an inborn difference of "head". It is the difference of a separate room for study, of a quiet house, of regular nourishment, of private lessons, of the cram school, of a parent who reads, of a table where the calculation of fractions can be a subject of conversation at supper. It is the difference of crowded classrooms, of double-shift teaching, of hourly-paid teachers who change continually. When the school year opens (The Bell Does Not Ring the Same for Everyone) we set out these material conditions one by one.
Education is, moreover, increasingly becoming a household burden. According to TÜİK data, in 2024, 18 lira of every 100 lira of education spending went to private institutions. (Bloomberg HT) Education spending by households and private sources rose from 75.8 billion lira in 2020 to 529.5 billion lira in 2024. (CNBC-e) As success in mathematics becomes a good that can be bought with money, the legend of "a head for mathematics" turns into a story that consoles those who cannot buy that good, and in fact silences them.
For this reason, the first and most important thing a teacher can do in order to make a student love mathematics is to break this legend: Mathematics is learned. Everyone can learn it. Your difficulty at this moment is not your lack. It is the lack of the conditions that have been offered to you until today.
Hegemony: How Is Consent to Inequality Produced?
To understand why the legend of "a head for mathematics" stands so firmly, one has to stop with Antonio Gramsci. In the Prison Notebooks, which he wrote in Mussolini's prisons, Gramsci showed that the ruling class does not maintain its power only by force, by the police, and by the courts. A lasting domination also has to win the consent of the ruled. This consent is produced in the school, in the family, in the mosque, in the newspaper, in language, and in the everyday truths that "everyone knows". Gramsci called this mass of shared acceptances "common sense" (senso comune). When the world-view of the ruling class seeps into the common sense of the oppressed, the oppressed count their own condition as natural, inevitable, even deserved. This is what is called hegemony. (Rejecting the Ruling Class’s Playing Field: The Reality of Hegemony, Passive Revolution, and an Independent Class Line)
The sentences "I am not the quantitative type", "no engineer comes out of our family", "that one was born clever anyway" are pieces of such a common sense. The person who first utters these sentences is often not the teacher or the minister. It is the child, the mother, the father. Inequality wins its strongest form when it speaks from the mouth of the oppressed. While introducing Nursel Tabel Arslan's book (The Consent of Labour: Why Does the Worker Submit, and When Does the Worker Stand Up?) we discussed why the worker submits. The same mechanism works in the classroom. In Reproduction, the French sociologists Pierre Bourdieu and Jean-Claude Passeron tell in detail how the school accomplishes this: the school rewards, as "natural talent", the cultural capital that wealthy families have accumulated at home, and it certifies the poor child's deprivation as "lack of talent". In the end a class sorting looks like the result of a fair and neutral competition. This is also why Louis Althusser placed the school at the head of the ideological apparatuses.
The examination system is the most productive machine of this production of consent. A million children solve the same questions on the same day, and the result is announced as a single number, a percentile band. No one asks, "Did this child have a desk for study at home?" The number appears to have said everything. The percentile band is the hegemonic language of inequality. As we showed in the essay where we discussed that words too have a class (On Getting Free from the Language of Hegemony), the words with which we think also determine what we can think. To say "a student whose conditions have been taken away", in place of "an unsuccessful student", is to see the same reality with another class's eye. (Why We Are Done Saying "the Woman Problem" and "the Kurdish Problem")
One more warning has to be taken from Gramsci. He was opposed to the school of workers' children being a school that is "made easy", passed over with play, and that asks for no labour. For him, to study and to learn is a labour, a craft that asks for muscle and nerve. The children of the ruling class acquire this habit at home, while the children of workers can acquire it only at school. Counter-hegemony is not built by diluting knowledge. It is built by opening the highest knowledge to the access of the oppressed. For this reason, to make mathematics loved is not to make mathematics easy, and it is not to empty it out. To make mathematics loved is to convince the child that the child can succeed at a difficult thing, and to build the conditions of that together with the child.
Looked at from this angle, the teacher is one of the most concrete forms of what Gramsci called the "organic intellectual": either the teacher reproduces the ruling common sense and says "your head cannot take it", or the teacher becomes a founder of the counter-hegemony by making it possible for the oppressed to trust their own minds. (Piercing the Darkness with the Mind of Labor: Organic Enlightenment and the Compass of Class)
Where Did Mathematics Come From? The Abstracted Mind of Labour
One of the strongest ways to make a child love mathematics is to tell the child where mathematics came from. Because mathematics is not, as it is presented in the textbooks, a list of rules that descended from the sky. Mathematics is the form, distilled over thousands of years, of the solutions people found to the problems they met while working together, producing, and sharing.
The Nile Flood and the Rope-Stretchers
In ancient Egypt the Nile flooded every year and wiped away the boundary stones of the fields. When the water withdrew, the fields had to be measured again, and it had to be determined who had how much land and therefore how much tax they would pay. The Egyptian measurers, whom the Greeks called "rope-stretchers", built right angles with knotted ropes and calculated areas. The word "geometry" itself already means "measurement of the earth". The Rhind Papyrus (around 1650 BCE) is full of everyday problems of production, from the sharing of bread and beer to the volume of a grain store.
In Babylon the calculations written on clay tablets are about numbers of bricks, quantities of mortar, workers' daily wages, and how many people would carry how much earth in how many days in the digging of canals. The first pages of mathematics are the account of labour.
Harezmi's Algebra and the Merchant's Ledger
The name of the field we today call "algebra" comes from the book of Harezmi, who lived in Baghdad in the 9th century: al-Kitab al-Mukhtasar fi Hisab al-Jabr wa'l-Muqabala. A large part of this book is given over to problems of the division of inheritance, of trade, and of the measurement of land. Harezmi's name, Latinised, also became the word "algorithm". The name of the algorithms that today manage the worker and draw the courier's route comes from a master of calculation who tried to divide an inheritance fairly. This irony is worth sharing with students.
In 1202 Fibonacci's Liber Abaci carried the Hindu-Arabic numerals to Europe through merchants. In 1494 Luca Pacioli set double-entry bookkeeping down in writing in a systematic way. The birth of capitalism is intertwined with the birth of accounting, of interest, of insurance, and of the calculation of probability.
Engels, Hessen and Struik: The Social Roots of Mathematics
In Anti-Dühring, Engels stresses that even the object of pure mathematics is the spatial forms and the quantitative relations of the real world, and that mathematics takes its concepts not from the head but from the external world. Mathematics is abstract, but it is not an abstraction hanging in a void. It is the abstraction of real relations. Numbers come from fingers, geometry from the field, probability from games of dice and from insurance calculations. In our essay Grasping Science and Philosophy by the Dialectical Method we treated this relation in a wider form.
In 1931, at the International Congress of the History of Science in London, the Soviet physicist Boris Hessen presented his famous paper relating Newton's Principia to the problems of navigation, mining, ballistics, and trade in that period. This paper began a whole tradition of investigating the social roots of science. The Marxist mathematician Dirk Struik, too, in his book A Concise History of Mathematics, told the development of mathematics together with the social conditions that gave birth to it.
This history says the following to the child: Mathematics is the common mind of the ancestors of the working class, of the people who tilled the soil, raised walls, built ships, and carried goods. What stole mathematics, and turned it into a tool of elimination and into the password of an elite's language, is the order we live in. To make mathematics loved is to return a stolen inheritance to the child.
The Two Faces of Mathematics: The Calculation That Saves, the Calculation That Dominates
To tell mathematics only as "a wonderful tool that makes our lives easier" would be incomplete, and even misleading. Mathematics is a tool, and like every tool it does different work according to whose hand it is in.
Taylor's Stopwatch
At the beginning of the 20th century Frederick Taylor measured every movement of the workers in the factories with his stopwatch, divided them into seconds, and calculated the "most efficient" sequence of movements. This was one of the most naked examples of the use of mathematics as a whip over labour. Today the same logic, as algorithmic management, measures the time per package in the warehouses, the courier's every stop, and the call-centre worker's every second. What we have many times called "mental Taylorism" on this blog is the form mathematics takes in the hands of capital.
Weapons of Math Destruction
In her book Weapons of Math Destruction, the mathematician Cathy O'Neil told how mathematical models, from credit scoring to hiring filters, from teacher performance scores to crime-prediction software, turn into machines that punish the poor, reproduce inequality, and, because they look "objective", cannot be objected to. A decision that hides behind a formula appears to abolish the responsibility of the human being who makes the decision.
The Boss's Mathematics, the Worker's Mathematics
In everyday life, too, mathematics has two sides. The mathematics that prepares the bank's table of minimum payments on the credit card knows that compound interest, while the debt is paid slowly, makes one pay many times the principal. The citizen who does not know this loses a game they do not know. When the boss prepares the payroll, the boss knows the deductions, the bonuses, and the tax brackets. The worker often cannot understand why the wage came in lower than last month. TÜİK announces an inflation, and the unions and independent researchers announce another figure. To be able to question which one measures what (September Inflation, the TÜİK-ENAG Gap) is a matter of mathematical literacy.
For this reason one has to say plainly to the student: Not knowing mathematics does not make you neutral. It leaves you defenceless in a game built by those who know mathematics. To learn mathematics means to be able to read the calculations others make about you, to be able to audit them, and, when necessary, to be able to refute them.
A Game, or a Work?
In the continuation of the conversation Baki Hoca asked three questions. What makes mathematics difficult and terrifying when it is no different from the games children play while enjoying themselves? What work does the teacher do in this process? Especially in the primary school, why do we spend so much time and labour turning this enjoyable instrument into a difficult lesson? The second question was this: What kind of subject is mathematics, such that the student who succeeds in it is, for the most part, successful in the other subjects too? The third stands like a choice: Is doing mathematics serious work, or is it enjoyment itself?
While the Rule Is in the Child's Hands, There Is No Fear
A child playing hopscotch counts the squares, sets the turn according to the square the stone falls in, and separates the cheat from the rule. In hide and seek the child counts. In marbles the child looks for distance and for a true aim. In cards the child divides the pack, reads the hand, and guesses what remains across the table. None of these works is stamped "mathematics" in the textbook. All of them are an argument about number, order, pattern, probability, and fairness. The child does not abandon the rule because it is difficult. The rule is the game itself. Difficulty does not produce fear here. The child knows why the rule is there. Across from the child there is a playmate with whom the rule can be changed together.
The school, for the most part, puts another stake on this game. The rule stays. The stake changes. A wrong step no longer only loses the game. It ranks the child, stamps the child with "the head does not take it", and drops the family's face at the supper table. The first years of primary school are the hour of this change. The child does not yet know the LGS, the YKS, or the KPSS. What the child knows is that the one who says it quickly at the board is applauded, that the one who raises a hand and errs is shamed, and that the pencil is put down when the time ends. Turkey's taking first place in mathematics anxiety in PISA is measured at the age of fifteen. The field of that anxiety is the primary school. The fear at fifteen is the taking of the game out of the hands at eight.
This is not to be read as "let us turn everything into a game, let us turn mathematics into entertainment". Gramsci was opposed to the school of workers' children being turned into a play-school that asks for no labour. Counter-hegemony is not the dilution of knowledge. What is said here is not that. The child's game is already labour. The square of hopscotch, like the step of a proof, is not an arbitrary ornament. It is a necessity accepted together. The child endures that necessity not because the result is a gate of elimination, but because the game is the child's own. The time and the labour the school spends are, for the most part, spent not in order to teach mathematics, but in order to pull up this belonging. The colourful slide and the speed chart can do the same work. One turns the game into an emptied entertainment. The other turns it into a threat. Both take the rule out of the child's hands.
What Does the Teacher Do at the Door?
The teacher is not a neutral transmitter at this moment. The primary-school teacher is the first witness of the relation the child will form with mathematics. In the classroom where the child can say "I do not know", where the mistake is sought together, and where it can be asked why a rule is so, mathematics remains a game. In the classroom where the child is afraid of the time, of the mark, and of the sentence "what will we tell your family", the same four operations become a court. In whose hand the chalk is, in that hand the rule of the game is either returned to the child or held against the child in the language of the curriculum and of the examination. (Whose Hand Holds the Chalk?)
This is not the loading of the whole burden onto the teacher's back. In a class of forty, with the hourly-paid teacher who changes every year, in double-shift teaching, in the home where no time remains in the evening to play, it is not easy for the teacher alone to give the game back. Even so, when the classroom door closes, the teacher's sentence is decisive. "Well done, you knew it quickly" and "Why did we set this rule up like this; let us break it together and set it up again" make two different lessons out of the same four operations. The first rewards speed and counts slow thinking as a fault. The second gives back to the child the real work of the game, the work of understanding the rule.
Why Does Success Spread to the Other Subjects?
The second question is the place where the legend of "a head for mathematics" takes refuge most. The child who succeeds in mathematics mostly appears successful in Turkish, in science, and in social studies too. From this the conclusion is drawn that "that one was born clever anyway". Yet what spreads is not a hidden talent. What spreads is two separate things. They have to be kept from being mixed together.
The first is a habit of thinking. Mathematics teaches a person to set a problem up, to separate what is given from what is asked, to say why one step gives birth to the next, and to look at the result that comes out and ask "is this reasonable?" This habit also works in understanding a paragraph, in reading a map, in discussing the result of an experiment, and in asking about a deduction on a payslip. Proof is a democratic habit here too. If the child has learned, in one subject, not to submit without a reason, the child does not count "that is just how it is" as an answer in another subject either. Mathematics therefore ceases to be a separate shelf. It becomes the common mind of all the subjects. Success spreads from here.
The second is the spreading of the conditions together. A quiet room, a regular table, a parent who reads, private lessons, a class that is not crowded, a teacher who does not count the mistake as shame: these raise not only the mathematics mark, but all the marks at once. The gulf between the wealthiest quarter and the poorest quarter is not the secret of a single subject. The same table, the same room, and the same wallet appear in the science question too, and in the question of understanding what one has read. The sentence "the one who is good at mathematics is good at every subject" is, for the most part, the covert form of the sentence "the one whose conditions have not been taken away is good at every subject". The first spreading is a reason for opening mathematics to everyone. The second spreading is a warning not to call inequality "intelligence".
Serious Work and Enjoyment Are Not Each Other's Opposite
The last question has been set up like a question of choice. Is doing mathematics serious work, or is it enjoyment itself? It is both at once. Its seriousness does not come from its not being enjoyable. Its being enjoyable does not come from its not being serious. Gauss's pairing of the numbers from the beginning and from the end, and his finding of 5050, was a game, and it was a serious discovery. Eratosthenes's stick can be set up like a children's game, and it gives the circumference of the Earth. The opening of a proof, the appearance of a pattern, is a pleasure proper to the human being. This pleasure is not an ornament outside labour. Labour turns into pleasure right there.
The school and the examination set up the real split. The examination blesses mathematics as "serious", and it defines seriousness as fear, speed, and elimination. Some "fun mathematics" packages brought out against this, in their turn, drive seriousness away. They turn the beauty of the pattern and the necessity of the rule into an emptied activity. Both are the same error. One takes the game out of being work. The other takes the work out of being a game. What the child needs is a serious game whose rule is the child's own. It is difficult, because there is a rule. It is not terrifying, because defeat is not a stamp. Defeat is the beginning of the next round.
For this reason the time and the labour spent in the primary school do not have to go to waste. That labour can be spent not in order to hide the game behind the textbook, but in order to make visible the labour inside the game. The teacher's role is not to make mathematics easy. The teacher's role is to say that the game the child is already playing is mathematics, to set the rule up together with the child, and to show that the mistake is not a reason for being thrown out of the game. Mathematics then remains serious work, and it does not cease to be enjoyment itself.
What Can the Teacher Do? Ways of Making Mathematics Loved in the Classroom
What has been said up to here should not push a teacher into pessimism. However heavy the system may be, when the classroom door closes there is a field that the teacher and the student can build together. As was also stressed in the conversation with Baki Hoca, a teacher's stance can determine the relation a child will form with mathematics for a whole life.
Breaking the Fear: A Mistake Is Not a Crime
Jo Boaler, a researcher in mathematics education, has for years examined how the beliefs students carry about mathematics affect success. One of the conclusions she reaches is plain: making a mistake is not an accident outside learning. It is learning itself. The brain builds new connections at the moments it struggles and errs.
What does this mean in the classroom?
- To ask "How did you think this?" in place of correcting a wrong answer at once. Behind most wrong answers there is a meaningful thought that stumbled somewhere.
- To write a wrong solution on the board and ask the students to find the mistake. The mistake turns into an object hunted together.
- To make the one who thinks deeply visible, in place of rewarding the one who answers quickly. Mathematics is not a speed race.
- To legitimise saying "I do not know". That the teacher too can from time to time say "I do not know this either; let us look together" teaches the child that thinking is an honourable process.
The LGS rule that "three wrongs cancel one right" is the logic of the elimination system: do not take a risk; if you are not sure, leave it blank. The logic of learning is the exact opposite of this: take the risk, try, err, try again. In the classroom the teacher can build a refuge against this logic of fear that the examination system imposes.
Starting from Life, Returning to Life
In Pedagogy of the Oppressed, the Brazilian educator Paulo Freire criticised the model in which the teacher deposits knowledge into the student's head as one deposits money, and he called it "banking education". Freire taught peasants to read and write with "generative words" that came out of their lives: land, wage, well, brick. The word, while naming the peasant's world, at the same time turned into a tool for questioning that world. We discussed in detail, in our essay On Getting Free from the Language of Hegemony, how Freire's method meets Gramsci's grasp of hegemony: when the oppressed begin to name the world in their own words, the spell of the ruling common sense begins to come apart.
The same thing holds for mathematics. A problem of two taps filling and emptying a pool touches no one's life. A problem that comes out of the student's life both explains that world and questions it.
The American mathematics teacher Eric Gutstein tried this path in the working-class neighbourhoods of Chicago, with students most of whom were of Latin American origin. In the lessons he tells of in his book Reading and Writing the World with Mathematics, students examined mathematically the rates of rejection of housing credit, the rent increases in their neighbourhoods, and the statistics of police stops by race. The students both learned ratio, percentage, probability, and the reading of graphs, and saw the relations of power that shape their own lives. Gutstein's finding was that in this process the students approached mathematics much more willingly, because mathematics was now a weapon that belonged to them.
Let us think of a few problems that could be built with this approach in any classroom in Turkey:
- The minimum wage and the food basket. With the minimum wage, how many kilos of bread, how many kilos of meat, how many litres of milk could be bought in a month? How much could be bought ten years ago? Here ratio, percentage, inflation, and the drawing of a graph are learned together.
- The electricity bill. With a tiered tariff, how does the bill change if the household's yearly consumption passes a certain limit? (The Class of Three Thousand Kilowatt-Hours) Linear and piecewise functions come alive on a bill.
- The rise in rent. A rent that rises every year with a ceiling of 25 per cent: in five years, how many times the first rent does it become? This is compound growth itself.
- Credit-card debt. Someone who pays only the minimum amount: in how many months, and by paying how many lira in total, do they close a debt of 10,000 lira? Examples that tell the power of the exponential function better than this are few. We told how credit turns into an apparatus of class discipline in our essay The Mortgaging of Our Future: A Manifesto for Young Comrades on Financial Bondage and the Credit Card.
- Two inflation figures. Why do the official and the independent calculations of inflation come out different? The concepts of weighted average, basket, and sample gain their meaning here.
- The school itself. Class size, the number of students per teacher, the school's budget, the canteen prices. The child learns statistics with the data of their own school.
- The earthquake and the safety of buildings. To understand why a structure collapsed, with concepts such as the strength of concrete, the cross-section of a column, and the class of the ground. This is the place where mathematics saves lives, and where neglect takes lives.
These problems show the student that mathematics is not something that "might be needed one day". It is a power working today, at this moment, at the family's table. The child, moreover, finds something to tell the family on returning home: "Mother, I calculated the rise in the rent; in five years it rises to nearly three times." At that moment mathematics crosses the walls of the school and becomes the mind of the household.
Algebra Is a Right of Citizenship
Bob Moses, one of the leading organisers of the civil rights movement in the United States, had struggled in Mississippi in the 1960s for the voter registration of Black people. Years later, in 1982, starting from his daughter's school, he founded the Algebra Project. For Moses, if the key to political participation in the middle of the 20th century was reading and writing, the key to economic participation in the information age was mathematical literacy. The child who cannot learn algebra was left outside the door of high-wage jobs, of technical professions, and of the university. For this reason Moses defined algebra as a right of citizenship, and in poor Black neighbourhoods he developed a method that teaches algebra by starting from the students' own experience (for example, a journey on the metro).
This view is instructive for us too. Mathematics is not a luxury, not the curiosity of an elite, and not an expertise needed only by those who will become engineers. Mathematics is one of the minimum conditions, in this age, of understanding one's own life and of defending it.
Not Only Useful; Beautiful
An important warning has to be made here. To try to make mathematics loved only through its usefulness also falls short. To say "this will be of use to you one day" again reduces mathematics to a tool, to a market value.
In his essay A Mathematician's Lament, the mathematics teacher Paul Lockhart likens the way mathematics is taught in schools to teaching music only through the rules of writing notation, and never letting the children hear a song. For him, mathematics is an art: a creative activity built on patterns, curiosity, and discovery.
An example. According to the story, the teacher of the young Gauss, in order to keep the class busy, asks them to add all the numbers from 1 to 100. Gauss finds the answer within a few minutes: 5050. He has paired the numbers from the beginning and from the end: 1 with 100, 2 with 99, 3 with 98. Each pair makes 101, and there are 50 pairs. To tell this story and to ask the students "What about from 1 to 1,000? And if we added the odd numbers?" calls them not to memorise the formula, but to discover it. The pleasure of discovery is one of the most basic pleasures proper to the human being.
To reserve this pleasure only for "talented" children, for olympiad teams, and for science high schools is also a class stance. To tell the child in a poor neighbourhood "you learn your practical job first", and to withhold the beauty of the pattern from that child, is to see the child not as a thinking human being, but only as labour power. As Fromm said (From Having to Being: Reading Erich Fromm with Class), knowledge is not an object of having. It is a mode of being. To know mathematics is not to be the holder of a diploma. It is to be someone who can look at the world in another way.
Proof: Submitting to Reason, Not to Authority
What separates mathematics from all other disciplines is proof. In mathematics a proposition, whoever says it, is not accepted as true until it is proved. The word of a famous professor, a minister's statement, the authority of a book, is not enough. But once it has been proved, the quietest child in the classroom too can follow that proof and see its truth for themselves.
This is, in a deep sense, a democratic act. The idea of proof says that every human being can reach the truth by way of reason, and that the truth is not a matter of rank or of office. As we saw in the essay where we discussed the mechanisms of deceiving ourselves (Neden Kendimizi Aldatırız? (in Turkish)), the human mind is extremely prone to false correlations and to groundless judgements. Mathematical thinking is one of the strongest antidotes humanity has developed against this proneness.
But the democratic character of proof is not protected of itself. As we wrote in the period when OpenAI announced that it had produced hundreds of mathematics papers (OpenAI's 722 Mathematics Papers and the Closed Laboratory of the General Intellect), in a science where the result is public and the machine that produces it is private property, the power to audit the proof can also pass into the hands of a handful of monopolies. To open mathematics to the people is also to open to the people the right to audit the proof.
When the teacher says to the child "let us show together why it is so", in place of "this formula is like this; memorise it", the teacher teaches the child something beyond mathematics: not to submit to any authority without a reason. This is a basic quality of the questioning citizen and of the organised worker.
Learning Together: A Pedagogy of Solidarity
In Turkey the learning of mathematics has to a great extent been constructed as an individual race: practice examinations, rankings, percentile bands, the "rival's" net scores. Yet learning is, in its essence, a social process.
The Soviet psychologist Lev Vygotsky's concept of the "zone of proximal development" explains this. There is a field between what the child can do alone and what the child can do with the help of an adult, or of a more knowledgeable peer. Learning takes place precisely in this field. What the child can do together with someone else today, the child does alone tomorrow.
In the classroom this means the following:
- To have students work in small groups on rich problems that they have to think about together.
- To encourage the student who has grasped a subject to explain it to a friend. The one who explains learns as much as the one who understands.
- To make the common success of the class visible; to reward not the "best" student, but the road covered together.
The tradition of "mathematics circles" (kružok) that developed in the Soviet Union in the 20th century was one of communities in which, after school, volunteer teachers and university people came together with children, solved problems, and discussed. Andrey Kolmogorov, one of the world's greatest mathematicians, took part in 1963 in the founding of the boarding school established in Moscow for children curious about mathematics, and he himself taught there. This tradition continues today in many places in the world as "math circles". In Turkey this field has to a great extent been filled by the dershane market, the market in private cram schools. The difference is plain. One organises mathematics as a common undertaking. The other organises it as a commodity.
There are also hopeful examples from Turkey. The Mathematics Village, founded in Şirince in 2007 under the lead of Ali Nesin, is an important experience in showing that mathematics can be built on curiosity and on thinking together, far from the pressure of examinations. Cahit Arf's lecture "Can a Machine Think?", given in public in Erzurum in 1958–59, is a fine example of a great mathematician's responsibility to share his knowledge with the people.
Mathematics in the Age of Artificial Intelligence
There is an objection often heard from students: "There is a calculator, there is a telephone, there is artificial intelligence; why should I do the calculation?" This question has to be taken seriously.
Yes, machines now do calculation much faster than we do. But mathematics was never only calculation. Mathematics is to set a problem up correctly, to choose which information matters, to sense whether a result is reasonable, and to question which assumptions a model rests on. Artificial intelligence produces an answer. To be able to check whether that answer is right is the work of the human being who knows mathematics. As we discussed in our essay The Human in the Loop, if the human who audits the work the machines produce loses the skill of auditing, the human in the loop turns into an ornament.
More than that, an important part of the things that govern our lives today are mathematical models: hiring algorithms, credit scores, social-media feeds, pricing systems. A society that does not understand these models remains wholly defenceless before the monopolies that built them. For this reason the age of artificial intelligence does not make mathematics unnecessary. On the contrary, it turns mathematical literacy into a tool of self-defence. We discussed the class consequences of handing thinking over to the machine in our essays The Class of Cognitive Surrender and Whom Is the University For? Artificial Intelligence, Cognitive Surrender and the Class of Thinking, and the turning of schools into captive customers of artificial-intelligence monopolies in our essay Google Classroom's Real Class.
The Teacher Is Not Alone: The Material Conditions of Teaching Mathematics
While telling the responsibility that falls to the teacher, one has to avoid falling into a trap: loading the whole burden onto the teacher's back. The discourse that "a good teacher accomplishes everything" makes invisible the crowded classrooms, the low wages, hourly-paid and contract teaching, the curriculum that changes continually, and the teacher's exhaustion.
In the essay where we told the class story of teaching (Whose Hand Holds the Chalk?), and in the essay where we took up the struggle of private-sector teachers (The Future Forged at the Ankara Barricades: The Class Struggle of Private-Sector Teachers), we told in detail that the teacher too is a worker, and that this labour is devalued. On the student's side the situation is no different. In a country where even at university eighty-two out of every hundred students have to work (Eighty-Two Out of a Hundred Students: Working While Studying Is Not a Choice, It Is a Class Position), the time to be set aside for mathematics is also distributed by class.
It is not easy to expect the rich pedagogy we described above from a teacher who is in a class of forty, who enters more than twenty hours of lessons a week, who cannot get by without doing extra work, and who is appointed to another school every year. Making mathematics loved also has material conditions:
- The lowering of class sizes, and the abolition of double-shift teaching.
- That teachers work on permanent, secure posts, and for a humane wage.
- That teachers be given time to prepare lessons, to work together with colleagues, and to develop themselves.
- Concrete material, a library, and laboratory facilities for mathematics in the schools.
- That the examination-centred system of elimination be replaced by the principle of equal and free public education.
These demands are not won by individual effort. They are won by organised struggle. That teachers come together in their unions, parents in the school-family unions, and people in neighbourhood organisations is also a precondition of making mathematics loved.
The Calculation That Looks at the Sky: Curiosity, the Future, and the Pale Blue Dot
Perhaps the oldest and strongest way to make a child love mathematics is to show the child the sky. Humanity did not develop mathematics only in order to measure the field and calculate the mortar. It also developed it in order to seek an answer to the question that wakes inside when one lifts one's head and looks at the stars: What is there, where are we, where are we going? Curiosity is one of the things that make the human being human, and the language of that curiosity in the universe is mathematics.
From a Stick's Shadow to the Circumference of the Earth
In the 3rd century BCE, Eratosthenes, who lived in Alexandria, noticed that on the summer solstice the noon sun in Syene to the south (today's Aswan) went down to the bottom of the wells, while at the same hour in Alexandria a stick standing upright cast a short shadow. He measured the angle of the shadow. He knew the distance between the two cities. The rest was geometry. He had in his hand neither a telescope nor a satellite. With a stick, a shadow, and the knowledge of proportion, he calculated the circumference of the Earth with a surprising closeness.
When this story is told in the classroom, the spell of mathematics appears of itself. Today the students in any school can do Eratosthenes's experiment again, by measuring the shadow on the same day and at the same hour with another school kilometres away. A stick, a ruler, a little trigonometry, and a solidarity established between two schools. One does not have to be rich in order to measure the Earth.
The Planet Discovered at the Tip of a Pen
Another example that shows the power of mathematics in the sky is Neptune. In the 19th century astronomers noticed that the orbit of Uranus did not fit the calculations exactly. The French mathematician Urbain Le Verrier thought that this deviation came from the gravity of a planet not yet seen, and he calculated on paper where that planet had to be. In 1846, at the Berlin Observatory, Johann Galle turned his telescope to the point Le Verrier had indicated, and he found Neptune right there. A planet had been discovered in the equations before it was seen by the eye.
Kepler's laws of the planets were distilled by mathematics from the data of Tycho Brahe's meticulous observations, which had gone on for years. The gravitational waves Einstein predicted in 1916 were measured directly for the first time in 2015, in the LIGO detectors. When the image of a black hole's shadow was presented to the world for the first time in 2019, that image had been obtained by mathematical methods that combined radio telescopes from every side of the world like a single giant telescope. Every great leap of science took place by a question of curiosity being worked patiently with mathematics.
The Invisible Labourers of Space Travel
Space travel is often told as the story of astronauts and of geniuses. Yet behind every rocket and every probe there is a crowded army of labour. When the Soviet Union sent Sputnik into space in 1957, and Yuri Gagarin in 1961, behind this stood the collective labour of thousands of engineers, technicians, and calculators. We told the class and political background of the space race in detail in our essay The Space Race from Sputnik to Starlink.
In the first years of NASA in the United States, an important part of those who did the orbital calculations were women called "computers". Among them were Black women mathematicians such as Katherine Johnson. In a period when discriminatory laws were in force, working in segregated sections and for low wages, they did the calculations that brought the astronauts home safely. For many years their names were not spoken. This story shows, in a striking way, that mathematics is not the work of "geniuses" alone. It is also the work of labourers who were made invisible.
That the Voyager probes could visit Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune in a single journey was also a victory of mathematics. The orbital calculations that used the planets' gravity to fling the probe from one planet to the next were possible thanks to a rare alignment of the planets that formed only at the end of the 1970s, and the calculations made in order to catch this opportunity had begun decades earlier. Today Voyager 1, as a human-made object, is arriving for the first time at a distance of one light-day from Earth. We told this forty-nine-year journey, and the common labour behind it, in our essay A Human-Made Object Is a Light-Day from Earth for the First Time.
The Pale Blue Dot
On 14 February 1990, as Voyager 1 travelled towards the outside of the Solar System, at the insistent suggestion of the astronomer Carl Sagan it turned its cameras back, one last time, towards the Earth. In that photograph, taken from about six billion kilometres away, the Earth appeared as a pale blue dot, smaller even than a pixel, inside a beam of sunlight.
In his book Pale Blue Dot, published in 1994, Sagan left an unforgettable reflection on this photograph. He reminded us that everyone we love, every human being we know and whose name we have heard, all the empires, all the wars, all the "heroes" and the "cowards", all the kings and the peasants, lived their lives on that small dot. He wanted us to think of the rivers of blood that generals and emperors have shed in order to rule, for a moment, a tiny piece of that dot. And he stressed this: there is no sign that anyone will come from somewhere else to save us from ourselves. The responsibility to treat one another better, and to protect the only home we know, belongs to us.
This photograph is one of the strongest images a mathematician, an engineer, or a teacher can show their students. Because it teaches two things at the same time. The first is that what lets us grasp the scale of the universe is mathematics: without calculating six billion kilometres, the light-year, and how many kilometres a pixel corresponds to, we cannot grasp the meaning of that photograph. The second is how meaningless, in the face of that scale, are borders, racism, wars, and the domination a handful of people have established over the labour of billions of people. The pale blue dot is a cosmic reminder of class solidarity. We are all in the same small ship, and to steer that ship according to the pleasure of a few people is to put the future of all of us in danger.
The Class of the Right to Look at the Stars
But a question also has to be asked: Who can look at the stars today? A child growing up in the poor neighbourhoods of the great cities will perhaps never see the Milky Way in a whole life, because of light pollution. The sky is increasingly filling with thousands of commercial satellites. Astronomers' right to observe conflicts with the commercial interests of a handful of companies. We discussed this enclosure in our essay Satellite Crowding and the Class of the Right to Observe.
Space, too, like mathematics, ought to be a commons, and it is increasingly turning into the private race of billionaires. As we wrote when the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope was launched (To Look Far Is to Look Into the Past), the difference between the open data that public science produces and the closed projects of private companies is the question of whose curiosity is at work, and for whose future. The introductory lesson we wrote for those who have never looked at the sky (An Explosion at the Dawn of the Universe: An Introductory Lesson for Those Who Have Never Looked at the Sky) was there for exactly this reason. The sky belongs to everyone, and the tools for understanding it must belong to everyone too.
In Turkey's own history there is also a bitter example of this tension. The observatory Takiyüddin founded in Istanbul in 1577 was one of the most advanced observatories of the period. Only a few years later, in 1580, it was destroyed under the pressure of the palace and of religious circles. When curiosity touches the interest of power, it is not tolerated. Today, too, if science budgets are cut while the budgets allocated to religious institutions grow many times over, this is not a coincidence.
Our Curiosity Will Always Go On
Even so, curiosity is something that can be suppressed, but that can never be killed. From Eratosthenes's stick to Takiyüddin's observatory, from Gagarin's journey to Voyager's golden record, humanity in every age looked at the sky again, asked again, and calculated again. New observatories were founded in place of the ones destroyed, and the knowledge of the books that were burned was written again in other hands.
There was a thought Sagan often voiced: we are a way for the universe to begin to know itself. With our bodies, made of atoms cooked inside the stars, we try to understand the universe itself. This thought is one of the most beautiful things that can be said in order to make a child love mathematics. When you solve an equation, when you notice a pattern, when you calculate a planet's orbit, the universe, through your mediation, knows itself a little more.
Our curiosity will always go on. The questions we cannot solve today will find their answer tomorrow in a classroom, in a village school, in a neighbourhood solidarity group, perhaps in the hands of a child who is afraid of mathematics today. The future will belong to those who do not lose their curiosity. And that future will be built by those who take curiosity out of being the privilege of a handful of people and make it everyone's right.
How Do We Tell All of Humanity about Mathematics?
This was the largest question of the conversation: beyond the classroom, how do we tell the value of mathematics to the millions who have long since left the age of examinations behind?
The Tradition of Mathematics for the People
In 1936 the English biologist and socialist thinker Lancelot Hogben wrote a book called Mathematics for the Million. Hogben's aim was to tell mathematics to ordinary workers who had left the school bench, through the social needs that gave birth to it. The book became a bestseller. It showed that mathematics can be understood by everyone, provided it is told by establishing its bond with its history and with life.
The experience of the Village Institutes in Turkey had also shown that knowledge, mathematics, and technique could be taught to peasant children, intertwined with production. The common point of these experiences was that they saw knowledge not as an elite privilege, but as a tool with which the people transform their own lives.
Mathematics Is a Commons
Perhaps the most beautiful side of mathematics is that it is, in its essence, a commons. The proofs in Euclid's Elements have belonged to everyone for more than two thousand years. No one can patent the Pythagorean theorem. A prime number has no copyright. For thousands of years mathematicians have built a collective structure, with open proofs, by building on one another's results.
There is also a current symbol of this spirit. After proving the Poincaré conjecture, one of the most famous problems of the century, the Russian mathematician Grigori Perelman published his proof not in a journal, but in an open preprint archive that everyone can reach. In 2006 he refused the Fields Medal, and in 2010 he refused the Millennium Prize of one million dollars. Setting Perelman's personal preferences aside, this stance strikingly recalled that mathematics is a common inheritance of humanity that cannot be measured by market value.
Today mathematical knowledge is increasingly being fenced in: expensive textbooks, paid education platforms, subscription applications, private courses. To tell mathematics to everyone means to tear these fences down and to draw mathematics back into the common field. The principle we defend as Bilgi Müşterekleri holds here too: Knowledge belongs to everyone.
In What Language Shall We Tell It?
The first condition of telling mathematics to the people is to tell it in the language of everyday life, not in a frightening language. But everyday language does not mean a superficial language. As we saw in the essays where we criticised popular-science content (The Class's Answer to Evrim Ağacı's Question), presenting knowledge as "fun" while erasing its social context can inform people and, at the same time, naturalise the existing order. While telling mathematics to the people, the aim must not be only to offer "interesting facts". It must be to make it possible for people to read, and to question, the calculations in their own lives. Without forgetting that words too have a class (On Getting Free from the Language of Hegemony), mathematics has to be freed from the language of elimination and of humiliation.
Concretely:
- Mathematics in union education. Reading a payslip, the calculations of a collective-agreement raise, the loss of the real wage against inflation. The strongest arguments in the worker's hand are often figures.
- Mathematics in neighbourhood and women's solidarity groups. The household budget, the traps of credit and debt, the calculation of bills.
- Public lectures and open workshops. As Cahit Arf did, the sharing of the knowledge in the university with the people, in an open and understandable form.
- Openly licensed materials. The sharing, in a form everyone can use, of lesson activities that teachers prepare and that are built with problems from life.
Two Mathematics: A Comparison
| The Mathematics That Eliminates | The Mathematics That Liberates |
|---|---|
| Mathematics is a tool of elimination and ranking | Mathematics is a tool for understanding and changing the world |
| Success depends on an inborn "head for mathematics" | Everyone can learn; success depends on conditions |
| The mistake is punished ("three wrongs cancel one right") | The mistake is part of learning; it is examined together |
| The formula is memorised | Why the formula is true is shown together |
| The problems are cut off from life (two taps, one pool) | The problems come out of the student's life (rent, the bill, the wage) |
| Learning is an individual race | Learning takes place through solidarity, together |
| The beauty of mathematics is reserved for "the talented" | The pleasure of discovery is every child's right |
| Curiosity is imprisoned in the examination booklet | Curiosity is as boundless as the sky; mathematics is its language |
| Knowledge is a commodity bought with money | Knowledge is everyone's common inheritance |
| In the hands of capital, mathematics is a tool of measurement and control | In the worker's hands, mathematics is a tool of audit and defence |
| Authority says what is true | Proof shows what is true |
| Inequality is presented as "talent", and the consent of the oppressed is produced | Inequality is called by its name, and the oppressed person's trust in their own mind is built |
| The game is split either into a frightening examination or into an emptied entertainment | The game is serious work; the rule is in the child's hands, and defeat is not a stamp |
Concrete Tasks
For Teachers
- Each term, to build at least a few lessons with problems that come out of the students' own lives: the wage, the price, the bill, the rent, the school's own data.
- To make the mistake visible and honourable in the classroom; to make the question "How did you think this?" a habit.
- In place of having formulas memorised, to show together with the students, at least for a chosen few of them, why they are true.
- To make group work, and explaining among peers, an ordinary part of the class.
- To scatter through the lessons the history of mathematics, and its bond with labour and with production.
- To share the lesson activities you prepare with your colleagues under an open licence; to grow together the commons of mathematics teaching.
- To make observations of the sky with the students; to set up Eratosthenes's experiment again by measuring the shadow on the same day together with another school, and to discuss the pale blue dot photograph together in the classroom.
- To organise in your union for class sizes, for the lesson load, and for wage demands; to defend collectively the material conditions of teaching mathematics.
- Beginning in the primary school, to set a subject up first as a game. Let the child be able to ask why the rule is there. Let a wrong move not be a reason for being thrown out of the game.
For Students
- To take the sentence "I am not the quantitative type" out of your life. Mathematics is learned.
- To try to read your family's bills, the rises in rent, and the payslips with a mathematical eye.
- To work together with your friends; to tell what you know, and to ask what you do not know.
- Not to give up asking why something is true. "That is just how it is" is not an answer.
- To write the rule of a game you play, and to ask why that rule is fair. Mathematics is already there.
For Parents and Neighbourhood Organisations
- To see the child's lack of success in mathematics not as "the head does not take it", but as the product of conditions.
- To found free and voluntary mathematics study groups in the neighbourhood, in associations, and in cooperatives; to organise alternatives based on solidarity against the dershane market.
- To form common demands, in the school-family unions, for crowded classrooms and for the lack of teachers.
For Trade Unions and Organisations of Labour
- To add to member education modules of basic mathematical literacy, such as reading a payslip, calculating the real wage, and interpreting inflation data.
- To develop tools, in collective-agreement processes, that make it possible for workers to calculate the figures themselves.
- Together with the unions of education workers, to build an open pool of lesson activities constructed with problems from life.
Dear young comrades,
Mathematics was offered to you for years as a fear, as a door, as a tool of elimination. Perhaps many of you felt inadequate in front of an examination paper, facing a question you could not solve. Perhaps someone told you "you have no head for mathematics", and you believed it.
Know that that sentence was a lie. Mathematics is the inheritance of the peasant who measured the field on the bank of the Nile, of the mason who calculated the mortar, of the master of calculation who tried to divide the inheritance fairly, of the sailor who steered the ship by the stars. It is the common mind of your ancestors, of the people who built the world with their labour. What took it from you, and turned it into an elite password and into a sorting machine, is the order we live in.
To take mathematics back is to take your mind back. It is to be able to read the calculation behind your rent, your bill, your payslip, the inflation figure you are told, and the algorithm that governs you. It is to be able to say "show me" when anyone says to you "this is how it is". And you can do this not alone, but together, teaching one another and learning from one another.
When one day you lift your head and look at the sky, remember that we live on that pale blue dot. On this small planet we are responsible towards one another, and our curiosity to understand the universe will never end. Eratosthenes's stick, Le Verrier's pen, Katherine Johnson's calculations, Voyager's journey: all of them are the work of this curiosity, and all of them the work of mathematics. It is your turn.
One day this sentence will be true for all of us: Mathematics is not a wall in front of anyone. It is a ladder in everyone's hand. We will build that day together. For more beautiful futures, all together.
Sources
Data and Reports
- Education Reform Initiative, PISA 2022 assessment: the bianet report
- "In Turkey the rich children are at the level of Switzerland, the poor children at the level of Moldova", haber.sol: link
- An assessment of mathematics anxiety in PISA 2022, Anadolu Agency: link
- PISA 2022 results and socioeconomic differences, BirGün: link
- Eğitim-İş, PISA 2022 Turkey assessment: PDF
- TÜİK Education Expenditure Statistics 2024, Bloomberg HT: link
- Education expenditure 2020–2024, CNBC-e: link
- LGS 2026 participation and net averages: tahtaapp, rehberpanda
Books and Theoretical Sources
- Friedrich Engels, Anti-Dühring
- Boris Hessen, "The Social and Economic Roots of Newton's Principia" (1931)
- Dirk J. Struik, A Concise History of Mathematics
- Lancelot Hogben, Mathematics for the Million (1936)
- Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed
- Lev Vygotsky, Mind in Society
- Eric Gutstein, Reading and Writing the World with Mathematics (2006)
- Robert P. Moses and Charles E. Cobb, Radical Equations: Civil Rights from Mississippi to the Algebra Project (2001)
- Cathy O'Neil, Weapons of Math Destruction (2016)
- Paul Lockhart, A Mathematician's Lament
- Jo Boaler, Mathematical Mindsets (2016)
- Erich Fromm, To Have or to Be
- Carl Sagan, Pale Blue Dot: A Vision of the Human Future in Space (1994)
- Carl Sagan, Cosmos (1980)
- Antonio Gramsci, Prison Notebooks
- Pierre Bourdieu and Jean-Claude Passeron, Reproduction: Principles of a Theory of the Educational System
- Louis Althusser, Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
Related Essays from Bilgi Müşterekleri
Hegemony, Consent and Language
- Rejecting the Ruling Class’s Playing Field: The Reality of Hegemony, Passive Revolution, and an Independent Class Line (14 August 2026)
- An Open Invitation to Deniz Zeyrek on the Reality of Hegemony and the Class Horizon (14 August 2026)
- On Getting Free from the Language of Hegemony (8 November 2026)
- The Consent of Labour: Why Does the Worker Submit, and When Does the Worker Stand Up? (9 November 2026)
- Why We Are Done Saying "the Woman Problem" and "the Kurdish Problem" (11 October 2026)
- The Masters' Ideological Siege: Exposing the Global "Whitewashing" Apparatuses (5 June 2026)
- Algorithmic Domination and the "Echo Chamber" Politics of Digital Capital (8 May 2026)
- The Political Economy of Perception: Epistemological Resistance in the Age of Cognitive Capitalism (19 June 2026)
- Piercing the Darkness with the Mind of Labor: Organic Enlightenment and the Compass of Class (6 May 2026)
- The Source Code of Class: The Great Integration of Intellectuals and Laborers (12 May 2026)
- Imperialist Decay, the Crisis of Hegemony, and Class Independence (26 July 2026)
School, the Teacher, and the Class of Thinking
- Our Education Dossier Is Out: Whose School Is It? (29 August 2026)
- The Bell Does Not Ring the Same for Everyone (13 September 2026)
- Whose Hand Holds the Chalk? (5 October 2026)
- The Future Forged at the Ankara Barricades: The Class Struggle of Private-Sector Teachers (18 June 2026)
- Eighty-Two Out of a Hundred Students: Working While Studying Is Not a Choice, It Is a Class Position (28 October 2026)
- Google Classroom's Real Class (3 November 2026)
- Whom Is the University For? Artificial Intelligence, Cognitive Surrender and the Class of Thinking (22 October 2026)
- The Class of Cognitive Surrender (4 November 2026)
- I Read It, So What? To Read Is to Be Active in Life (30 October 2026)
- The Human in the Loop (29 October 2026)
Mathematics, Proof, Science, and Everyday Calculation
- A Human-Made Object Is a Light-Day from Earth for the First Time (31 October 2026)
- To Look Far Is to Look Into the Past (1 September 2026)
- An Explosion at the Dawn of the Universe: An Introductory Lesson for Those Who Have Never Looked at the Sky (18 October 2026)
- The Space Race from Sputnik to Starlink (5 October 2026)
- Satellite Crowding and the Class of the Right to Observe (12 October 2026)
- OpenAI's 722 Mathematics Papers and the Closed Laboratory of the General Intellect (8 October 2026)
- Grasping Science and Philosophy by the Dialectical Method (6 August 2026)
- The Science Mask of Bourgeois Ideology: A Marxist Critique of Karl Popper and Celal Şengör's Fallacies (20 June 2026)
- Neden Kendimizi Aldatırız? (in Turkish) (30 October 2026)
- Revolutionary Discussion Ethics and Guide to Purging Fallacies (16 August 2026)
- From Having to Being: Reading Erich Fromm with Class (14 September 2026)
- The Mortgaging of Our Future: A Manifesto for Young Comrades on Financial Bondage and the Credit Card (21 July 2026)
- September Inflation, the TÜİK-ENAG Gap (5 October 2026)
- The Class of Three Thousand Kilowatt-Hours (31 October 2026)
- The Class's Answer to Evrim Ağacı's Question (7 September 2026)
This essay is published under the CC BY-SA 4.0 licence. It is a living document. It is updated with criticism and contributions.









